How Lucas Phillips Built New York Auto into a $2M/Year Vintage Car Parts Manufacturing Business

Introduction

When Lucas Phillips purchased a 120-year-old manufacturer of vintage car parts, he inherited a business stuck in the past with physical patterns on conveyor belts and manual manufacturing processes. This transform vintage car parts manufacturing business case study reveals how he modernized operations, built e-commerce capabilities, and grew revenue from $1.25 million to nearly $2 million through strategic acquisitions while navigating a challenging transition period.

Founder Success Story QnA

Please start us off explaining why it was you chose to buy a business in the first place

I bought my company to pursue ETA when I was 23 years old. I was coming off a 5-year journey building a startup with traditional equity financing while at Northwestern and after college. I learned so much from that experience, but I didn’t want to bootstrap something very slowly or constantly raise outside capital for improbable rocket-ship outcomes. A friend introduced me to the ETA idea, I read “Buy Then Build,” joined the Acquisition Lab, and moved back to New York to be closer to my father who’s a small business owner.

Your startup was a brick and mortar coffee business – would you consider that a success?

I started the business when I was 18 with money from my bar mitzvah and some credit card debt, owning 100% of the company. We called it Brewbike on Northwestern’s campus – a student-run coffee business that expanded to many other campuses. Then I teamed up with an MBA and expanded with capital from angel investors and family offices. I didn’t enjoy it as much doing that because of the growth expectations we had to meet to have a successful outcome. I helped support the company for additional years after transitioning from the small business at Northwestern and eventually positioned it to get through COVID.

Did your brick-and-mortar coffee business give you a taste of small business as we understand it?

Absolutely. I come from generations of small business owners – Jewish Ellis Island immigrants who came to New York and couldn’t get jobs, so they started businesses. That was my great-grandpa, my grandpa, and my dad. The comfort I have or eagerness to be in a small business comes from that as much as my experience with Brewbike.

Say more about your dad’s influence and why that served as motivation for you

When I think about why I chose this path, a lot has been my dad. I grew up in Manhattan in this high-pressure, high-wealth environment. I was one of the few students whose dad could drop me off at school or take me to hockey practice because he was a small business owner with control of his time, not working in investment banking or corporate law. We had a comfortable lifestyle – I attended private school, went to private college, had a second home for summers. Business ownership afforded us freedom compared to my friends whose fathers had wealth but golden handcuffs.

Your high school experience encapsulated the ‘king vs. rich’ framework. Do you want to be king or do you want to be rich?

That’s exactly it. My dad was king with freedom, while other fathers were rich with private jets but no freedom. I think there’s a lot of self-selection of ‘king’ types in this world. You could make a million dollars a year in corporate, but business ownership is about freedom. The Founder’s Dilemma book is all about this rich versus king outcome – very applicable to search world as Searchers consider funded vs. self-funded search.

Take us through your search process – what kind of business were you looking for?

I knew I wanted a physical product business, not services. I liked having something tangible. I was looking for companies with physical products being distributed B2B that were somehow differentiated, not commodity goods. I thought they were selling at lower margins than they would realize if they sold direct to consumer. I figured there could be companies with a story that could be told and a brand built around that product for D2C expansion using cash flow from B2B sales.

Did you worry about deal flow with such a specific thesis?

I didn’t find it super narrow because I wasn’t constrained by size – I was looking for something around $500k in SD. My family was going to help with the down payment since I was in my early 20s. I was also willing to look all across the US. I thought if I found something in a faraway part of the US, that business could probably be relocated fairly easily within a year or two. My dad has a large warehouse in Connecticut with extra room. Also, I don’t think many searchers had this thesis, so these deals weren’t getting much interest.

What was the exact business model of New York Auto and how did it fit your e-commerce criterion?

The business had a catalog of thousands of patterns – stencils on hangers, big pieces of paper with markings. Every single pattern fits different year, make, model, door number, body style cars from the early 1900s to early 2000s. The business model was offering these products on a made-to-order basis to online retailers of car parts. They’d send us orders and we’d drop ship on their behalf under either the New York Auto brand or private label. The process was there: order comes in, send to floor, cut fabric, sew fabric, ship it out, bill it.

$300,000 of SD in a century-old business suggests a small market. Why did you believe there was enough market opportunity?

It was clear the business had shrunk over time. The prior owner was an amazing operator but not a salesperson, not interested in expanding – he was happy earning a quarter million dollars a year. There was a point when it was much larger. I thought I could expand by improving the product line and selling direct to consumer. Another factor – I was 23 at the time. If I buy this business with $300,000 of SD and get it to over $500,000 of SD and either flip it or hire someone to run it by age 29, that would be a great outcome.

What were the acquisition terms for New York Auto?

I acquired the business for just under a million dollars including about $70,000 of inventory. It’s all raw materials – rolls of carpet I could immediately start converting into finished goods. It was 90% SBA loan, 6% fixed interest rate for 10 years. That was one of the best decisions I’ve made – fixing the rate when no one thought rates would go up. I paid about three-quarters of a point more to fix it. I don’t know if I’d be in business if I had a variable rate that went up to 12-13%.

What was your biggest challenge during transition and operations?

No one was showing up to work on time. There were five or six manufacturing workers, all related, none showing up on time – some at 8:15, others at 8:45, someone at 9:30 daily. The owner’s opinion was when they didn’t show up, he’d just get that work done and save a few dollars. He’d do it himself and was okay with that because he could do it faster than they could. This wasn’t a mentality that would allow business expansion. I was also struggling personally with the burden of debt and how poorly operations were versus my expectations.

You mentioned being ‘a mess’ personally during transition – can you elaborate?

I was an anxious wreck. I knew I’d need to get rid of all these people but I’d just bought a manufacturing company and didn’t know how to do anything. I only had 90 days with the seller to learn the business. I’d need to learn what they’re doing without them being there. Personally, my long-term relationship ended because I had no time to devote to it. I was losing sleep, waking up with panic attacks. The anxiety was getting in the way of solving business problems, so I went on an SSRI for a couple years to handle the stress.

What did you learn from offering significant raises for basic work standards?

I don’t think the amount someone earns is correlated to their qualities as a human being regarding being prompt and responsible. I offered a program where if you show up on time and work 40-hour weeks for four weeks, you’d get a raise to $15/hour. Of six manufacturing workers, four were gone within weeks. I was trying to change these people by saying ‘if I pay you $3 more an hour, will you change?’ The answer was no. I knew these people wouldn’t work out long-term but was thinking short-term about fulfilling orders.

How have you evolved as a manager since that difficult transition period?

I’ve learned how to fire well and trust my instinct when someone isn’t working out. When I start thinking ‘is this person dead weight?’, that’s probably the right time to talk to them. In the past, it was a much longer process to part ways. Because I’m comfortable with that now, I’m actually less hard as a manager. I want people to be themselves. We have core values: work smart, be a team player, and sweat the small stuff. If everyone embodies those, I don’t need to micromanage.

How have you modernized the business operations?

The first step was implementing a cloud ERP inventory system for managing manufacturing and understanding inventory levels. We use Zoho, a competitor to QuickBooks, and ShipStation for shipping instead of Worldship. We implemented these basic improvements step by step – replace one legacy system, then the next. Once done, we offshored office tasks. I had an office manager earning $75-80k/year who struggled with new systems, so I replaced her with a nearshore contractor in Bolivia for about $2,000/month, saving $50-55k annually.

What was the impact of implementing CNC machinery on the factory floor?

I needed to convert patterns to digital files for CNC cutting. The software and hardware cost about $20,000. Digitizing labor costs another $50,000/year. Additional machinery cost another $50,000 plus $30,000 for expansion. Without this, I couldn’t have scaled throughput – I couldn’t continue tracing patterns with chalk and cutting with hand scissors. The amount of training, quality control, and consistency needed would have made scaling impossible.

What are the results of e-commerce implementation for New York Auto?

We’re now generating more sales from our website than from all dealer accounts. The business grew from $1.25 million/year when I bought it to just under $2 million in 2024 – we’ll definitely break $2 million this year. We’ve more than doubled carpet sales (from about $750k to $1.5M) which are the items we manufacture in-house. I implemented an MSRP pricing model where dealers get a fixed discount from MSRP. I commit to only selling at MSRP, so they have price protection.

What is the average order value for your vintage car parts?

The average order value is in the $300-400 range, though some products like Porsche carpets might be $1,500. The value of coming directly to me is I’m a real specialist – if you want to work directly with the manufacturer for customization or specific fabric choices, you come to me. Dealers offer the convenience of buying all car parts from one place.

What have been the biggest challenges with your e-commerce implementation?

The biggest challenge has been the amount of vehicles we offer products for and different fabrics available. We’re talking hundreds of thousands of lines of data because it’s every permutation of every vintage car across different fabrics. For older vehicles, there aren’t easy databases, so we have to research all different permutations. One pattern might say ’68 to 72 GM midsize’ but we have to figure out all year, make, model, body, and door variations for that GM midsize.

Tell us about your bolt-on acquisitions since acquiring New York Auto

I realized I want as many patterns as possible, so I told dealers to let me know if suppliers wanted to retire. One dealer connected me with a headliner manufacturer in Georgia doing $150k/year in sales. I acquired it for $50k – now I have patterns for headliners on hundreds of cars I make carpets for. Then I found a Porsche parts business on eBay – after negotiation, acquired it for similar price. Most recently, I acquired assets from a shuttered business making parts for high-end European cars – for the price of a used car plus moving costs.

Is there a potential buyer for your business down the line?

I don’t think much about selling because I’m focused on what I need to do now to get to a point where I have that option. I haven’t spent time thinking about it, but there are potential buyers – private equity companies that have rolled up similar manufacturing businesses, and larger companies where mine would be complementary. As I grow and compete more with PE-owned competitors, they might want to eliminate me as competition to build a monopoly in this market.

Lucas Phillips Business Stats

Lucas transformed New York Auto from a struggling century-old manufacturer into a thriving $2 million/year business through strategic modernization and acquisitions. His journey shows how digitization and e-commerce integration can revitalize legacy manufacturing operations.

  • Purchased in 2021 for just under $1 million with $70,000 inventory
  • Grew revenue from $1.25 million to nearly $2 million annually
  • Reduced office management costs from $75-80k to $24k annually via nearshoring
Financial MetricValue
Initial Revenue (2021)$1.25M
Current Revenue (2024)Nearly $2M
Monthly Revenue~$166,667
Average Order Value$300-400
Seller’s Discretionary Earnings$300,000

Lucas Phillips Method

Lucas’s transformation of New York Auto followed a systematic approach that addressed inefficiencies while preserving the business’s valuable core assets. His method focused on incremental improvements that built toward significant operational transformation.

  • Implemented cloud ERP (Zoho) to replace Windows XP-based FoxPro system
  • Modernized shipping with ShipStation instead of legacy Worldship
  • Digitized physical patterns for CNC cutting machinery implementation
  • Offshored office management to Bolivia saving over $50k annually
  • Developed MSRP pricing strategy protecting dealer relationships while expanding D2C
  • Acquired complementary businesses to expand pattern portfolio

Lucas Phillips Tools

Lucas strategically deployed technology to modernize legacy operations without disrupting the business’s core value – its extensive pattern library and manufacturing capabilities. Each tool addressed specific pain points in the inefficient legacy systems.

  • Zoho as cloud ERP replacement for inventory management and cost tracking
  • ShipStation to streamline shipping operations and replace manual processes
  • Near for finding and managing nearshore office staff in Bolivia
  • CNC machinery to automate fabric cutting, replacing hand scissors and chalk tracing
  • Shopify as e-commerce platform with iterative improvements over time
  • AI tools (recently implemented) to manage the massive product catalog data

Key Notes

Several critical insights emerge from Lucas’s journey transforming a vintage manufacturing business. These observations highlight the unique dynamics of acquiring and modernizing legacy operations.

  • Valuable intellectual property existed in physical patterns that represented a significant moat
  • “Not trigger shy” approach helped him secure the right deal early in his search
  • Process existed but was inefficient – critical for successful transformation
  • Channel conflict managed through strategic MSRP pricing with dealer protections
  • Being “in the game” opened bolt-on acquisition opportunities with competitors
  • Digital transformation required significant upfront investment but enabled scaling

Get Started in Just 5 Steps

Following Lucas’s path to transform a legacy manufacturing business requires strategic planning and execution. These five steps outline how to approach a similar transformation journey.

  • Develop a specific acquisition thesis focused on physical product businesses with modernization potential
  • Find businesses with existing processes (even if inefficient) rather than complete chaos
  • Implement cloud-based systems incrementally to replace legacy technology
  • Create a pricing strategy that protects channel relationships while expanding D2C
  • Look for bolt-on acquisition opportunities to expand your intellectual property portfolio

Conclusion

Lucas Phillips’s journey transforming a 120-year-old vintage car parts manufacturer demonstrates how strategic acquisition and modernization can revitalize legacy businesses. By respecting the existing business model while modernizing operations, he grew revenue from $1.25 million to nearly $2 million through digital transformation and strategic acquisitions. The key was recognizing that the physical patterns represented valuable intellectual property that could be digitized and monetized through modern e-commerce channels while maintaining essential dealer relationships. His story proves that with the right approach, even century-old manufacturing businesses can be transformed into thriving digital-era operations.