How Matt Paulson Built a $14M Net Profit Email Marketing Business with MarketBeat

Introduction

In this interview, Matt Paulson shares how he built MarketBeat into a $14 million net profit email marketing business with 4.6 million subscribers and just 16 employees. Discover the strategies, challenges, and insights that helped him create one of the most successful financial media businesses through profitable email marketing.

Matt Paulson Success Story QnA

How did you build MarketBeat and what was the early journey like?

MarketBeat is really kind of an evolution of a couple different ideas that I’ve had in the past. Really started in 2006. I was doing freelance writing to make some money in college. I kind of figured out that I knew how to write so maybe I could make my own personal finance blog. This is back like in a peak of blogging when everybody had a blog and you were writing content and trying to promote it on social media. I did okay with that, nothing Earth shattering, probably $50,000 in a year. Then I did it for a couple years and the first kind of big stair step moving forward was switching from personal finance content to investing content because when you write about public companies that are stocks, you can get your content featured in Yahoo Finance and Google Finance and MSN money and places like that stock quotes where it’s really vertical search engines for stocks.

Were there any remarkable events or challenging periods in building MarketBeat?

You know, if you have a content website on the internet, your biggest fear is always that Google is going to change the algorithm and then your traffic goes away and your website is worthless and you’re not making money anymore. That was kind of the cycle that I was in. I would have a website, it would do great, it loads to too great and then it would get knocked down. This is the Google Panda update in 2011, the Google Penguin update 2012 when these algorithm changes were first starting to impact people like me. I had to escape this cycle of building a site up, getting it knocked down, building another site. This is just not sustainable long term.

What are the specific ways you’re making revenue with MarketBeat?

There’s three main ones. The biggest one by far is advertising. We have an email list of 4.6 million people, we have about 125,000 SMS subscribers, probably about half a million web push subscribers, and then 300-400,000 people on our website a day. So plenty of attention to monetize through advertising. Our three kind of big groups of advertisers are kind of boutique financial newsletter publishers, public companies looking for exposure, and then fintech providers that have like a new credit card or a new savings account that are looking for customers. Bucket two of revenue is subscriptions. We sell a product called MarketBeat access that costs $40 a month or $400 a year. Then we also sell a lifetime subscription for $1,000 that some people buy. Our third bucket of revenue is syndication. There are people that will pay us for our content. Lexus Nexus is our biggest customer for that.

Can you give us a short masterclass on how to build an email list?

I think it’s hard to utilize because you know it requires some work to do. It’s not just something that you can create a Twitter account and start posting in a few minutes. You have to go sign up with an email service provider. On my personal stuff I use ConvertKit, that’s worked really well for me. You have to create your account, pay them money, and then connect your domain name to send email. Then you have to go to your website and put an opt-in form on your website to collect opt-ins. Typically, “give me your email address” is not enough of a reason to get somebody to sign up, so you have to give people a reason to sign up. It’s either like a newsletter that you publish or maybe it’s a free course or a guide or video course, YouTube course, anything. You have to have some incentive for people to sign up on your website.

Why should one blog or run a weekly or monthly newsletter?

I don’t think people should blog anymore. I just think that as a medium has is dead, it’s moved all over to social media. I think there’s still value in a weekly email newsletter. For my personal stuff, like the Matt-branded stuff, I just send out something whenever I’ve got something interesting to say. Maybe I’m on a podcast and I want to send that out to the audience so they can listen to that or I publish a quarterly update. I think there’s a real value in that because it helps build your relationship with your audience on a one-to-many basis and over a long period of time, so it really builds trust on a topic.

What’s your take on the luck and skill ratio in building a successful business?

Obviously with every business it’s a little bit of luck in terms of timing and picking the right opportunity and then skill of being able to execute on it. I think I hit some pretty good timing in terms of just the internet becoming a part of everybody’s life and investments moving onto the internet. The COVID timing was great for us from the investing perspective. There are a lot of people who tried to do the same thing that we did during the same time and didn’t get anywhere because they didn’t have the skills. It is definitely a little bit of both. When I think about luck, MarketBeat wasn’t the only thing I tried. I had an audiobook website, a personal finance website, a press release distribution service, a service where I would fix people’s slow WordPress websites. When you increase the volume of things that you try, that will increase your surface area for luck.

Have you had mentors on this journey or have you been figuring things out yourself?

I definitely have some mentors but more on a personal side. Some friends here and there that are a few years older and wiser than me. That’s been really helpful in understanding what to get involved with in the community and what not to and how to spend my time. On the business side, haven’t had a whole lot for mentors. There’s a guy named John Newson who’s in the financial media space. He’s kind of an influencer of sorts. I’ve learned a lot about the industry from him. He’s been incredibly useful both meeting him and going to his event, and his YouTube content is just fantastic. So in the financial media space, I definitely consider him like a mentor.

What have been the biggest hiring mistakes and lessons at MarketBeat?

We’ve had employees for 11 years now, we have 16 currently, and we’ve only had three of them leave us either by choice or we told them like you’re fired. The mistakes that we’ve made are when there is a misalignment of incentives. I tried to bring on a business partner probably five years ago. The misalignment was that he had, I was all in on MarketBeat but he had three other things that he wanted to pursue at the same time, so MarketBeat just wasn’t getting the time that it was supposed to. The other kind of misalignment was we had an employee who had a side business and they were more concerned about the side business than their day job. When people have divided focus, you hire people that aren’t all in on their job or their business and have some other big part of their life that’s also making them money, that’s where I’ve had issues before.

What are the main reasons people go to work at MarketBeat?

We pay people really well. People love the culture, we’re nice to our employees. We have an employee who’s at home sick with their kid today, so we sent the kid flowers because the kid’s been sick for like 3 days. Little stuff like that where it doesn’t cost a ton of money but it tells them you care. A recent study about what employees really want in a job, pay is like number four and number one is being recognized by your supervisor, feeling you’re working on significant work, having good teammates, good culture, and then pay is like number fourth. I try really hard to recognize our employees when they do well, just show them that their work matters and that I value them and that goes such a long way.

Why did you decide to bootstrap MarketBeat and not raise funding?

You got to understand I live in South Dakota, it’s a very rural State and very limited venture capital. I started it when I was in a college town of 7,000 people so there was no Venture Capital. And if there was, like it was probably in Minneapolis four hours away so I didn’t even know it was a thing. I didn’t know it was an option. I knew a bank would give me a loan but I had no idea Venture Capital existed when I started MarketBeat.

Why are you so transparent about your business numbers?

That’s a good question because obviously your choice is to like never mention your numbers publicly, keep it totally private or share something. Ultimately I decided to share some information because you can’t really get the credibility that you want without it. So I really want to be seen as an email marketing expert that is really in the top of my field, top of the game. I like speaking at conferences, I like creating content, I publish some books and you can’t really do that without the credibility that goes behind it. When I first decided to build a personal brand, there were some other kind of email people that said you know I’ve got a list of 250,000 people and I’m making a million dollars a year on email. It’s like my numbers are way better than that but nobody gives a crap who I am because they don’t know my numbers.

What sets MarketBeat apart from other financial news platforms?

I’d say there’s a lot of similarities. We have a lot more tools than a lot of other investing news sites. A lot of different stock lists and stock screeners and tools like that. We have more of that. I would say our platform changes a lot more than others. We have a development team of five people and they’re always making improvements to the website. I think content is very similar. If you’re just thinking about MarketBeat as a website that people go to and read content, it’s very similar to other businesses. Where we are very unique is that we are a marketing machine. We drive more than 100,000 clicks a day to advertisers and of the you know we generate probably 35ish million this year at advertising revenue. That’s where we’re unique is we’re really good at generating sales for our customers.

What type of investments are you looking for outside of MarketBeat?

Financial media marketing companies from a business perspective are a lot like a marketing agency in that there’s not any hard assets. Your value is really the people and these other and really every month you’re kind of starting over as zero in terms of revenue. Media companies typically don’t sell at really high valuations. We recognize that so my wealth building play is not build up MarketBeat and sell it to somebody. It is to operate MarketBeat profitably as long as I can. If MarketBeat does 40 million this year and we make 20 million in net income on that, I’ll probably pay six million in taxes on that so that leaves me at 14 million. Maybe I live off a million on that and then you just go invest the rest of it. That’s kind of my wealth building plan.

Can you share about the challenges in building MarketBeat?

2016 was a bad year. My second child was born and my family was frankly a mess. MarketBeat didn’t grow, I thought about selling the business because I was burned out and out of ideas. Thankfully no one offered me more than three and a half times earnings which I was looking at the time, and I decided okay I better just keep running the business. In 2011, that was kind of the first bad year. We got married and then five months into our marriage my wife’s father died so that was not a good year. Then the next year we had a kid and my son Micah was born 10 weeks premature, weighed 3 pounds 1 ounce. That was a tough year. Then 2016 when Addie was born that was also a tough year. My wife Ken had a really tough pregnancy, very very difficult. Addie was also born premature, she was five and a half weeks premature. We had two premature babies, both had therapy, both have issues. My little girl Addie has a genetic condition that we didn’t learn until she was three. She’s eight years old now but her speech is pretty limited because of her rare genetic condition.

Can you tell us about the “wild times” during COVID?

It was weird but it was awesome. 2020 in COVID, nobody knew what was going on. We didn’t have a big drop in revenue in early 2020 like a lot of people did because the products that we tend to sell were like people buy at home anyway. It was kind of summer fall of 2020 when things just really started to shoot up. In November December of 2020, somebody posted on The Wall Street bets subreddit saying if we all just buy GameStop stock, the shorts could not buy enough stock to cover their positions and that would just keep driving the price up over and over and over again and then there’d be a short squeeze. GameStop stock shot just shot up through the moon. People were like what’s going on, like the rules of Wall Street have changed. The retail investors are back with a vengeance. They bankrupted or basically bankrupted a hedge fund doing that. People really thought the rules of investing had changed. Then they did the same thing with AMC Theaters during COVID when nobody was going to a movie theater.

Has MarketBeat looked at acquiring other email lists or businesses?

There have been situations, but what I’ve kind of seen is I haven’t really found anything worth buying because with an email list you really have to maintain it well and unsubscribe people that don’t open and you have to mail to it regularly. When somebody is selling a mailing list, it’s usually either not very big or it hasn’t been well maintained. So it tends not to be worth very much. The other thing is people try to sell me investing websites that have tools and then you have to inherit somebody else’s software development work that might be in a language that you don’t know or don’t use. You just inherit a lot of technical debt. We’ve strategically decided acquisitions aren’t going to be part of our strategy because it’s too much work, too much money for what you get from it.

How much do you spend on advertising and what’s your strategy?

We do a bunch of different stuff. Some of it is through different marketing agencies. A big one we work with is a company called Fon marketing. They are niche to the financial media publishing space and they spend about $300,000 a month for us. Some of it we do on our own, like all our YouTube spend and our Twitter spend is all internal. We work with different agencies. There’s another one called ntif, they buy placements in other people’s newsletters for us. You have to identify people who are good at one thing and then pay them to do that one thing and not have them do anything else. About a year ago we were spending maybe $300,000 a month on advertising. I figured out if we spend $300,000 in January, by the end of March we’ve probably broken even on that and then anything after that is profit. My thought was I’m just going to keep scaling this up by $100,000 a month until it stops working. We’re spending a million two a million three a month on Advertising and if it keeps working the way it has, we’re just going to keep growing it.

What are the biggest lessons from your career?

There are some really cool investing tools out there that are frankly better than MarketBeat but you know what they don’t have, 4 million email subscribers. A few lessons from my career: number one, distribution means more than product. Number two, build your audience using platforms other people are ignoring. Number three, email is best channel to build your audience on. Number four, work on same thing for 15 years for outsized success.

How do you manage running multiple businesses?

MarketBeat is probably 80% of my energy. Homegrown Capital and Crested are 10% projects. My partner Tim runs Homegrown Capital on a daily basis. My partner Kevin runs Crested Capital on a daily basis. They’re the operators. Those are five hour a week projects for me at most. I don’t have to put much time in them because I have great partners. That’s what it amounts to.

What motivates you to do what you do?

I like to do things that are fun. Whether it’s like a watch or a car or the plane that I bought last year or any of the community stuff we do in Sioux Falls, we’re going to sponsor 50 summer concerts this year. There’s a children’s science museum down the road and we’re helping revamp part of it. We just think these things are fun so we like to do them. It’s going to sound maybe stupid but it sounds fun and we can do it, we do it.

What are your thoughts on goal setting?

Be careful what goals you set in life because you may achieve them. Lots of people want to be extremely wealthy but that comes with a lot of demands on your time, people that want things from you and business complexity that you have to manage. It comes at a real price. People will see somebody who’s in business doing really well and kind of be jealous of that but there are some real costs that come with it. In Sioux Falls, everybody knows who I am. You go to the movie theater, somebody will say hi to you and want to talk for a couple minutes. Sometimes you just want to be anonymous. There’s always people asking you to get involved with their stuff, a lot of asks, a lot of meeting requests. There’s just this expectation that you give a lot of money away, that you serve on all these nonprofit boards. It can be a lot and there’s cost to this.

What motivates you today and what are your future plans?

This year we’re trying to hit 40 million in Revenue, I think we’ll do it. That’s kind of the big Financial goal this year. My future of MarketBeat is to run it until I’m 60 or 65 and then shut the door, close the doors and write a big check to my employees and call it a day. I’m kind of on the never sell bus. I love running a business, I’m going to run it as long as I can and pay my people well along the way. I don’t really plan to sell it. There’s a guy in town his name is Scott Lawrence but he runs the largest advertising agency in town. He’s probably in the 60s now and he never retired. He keeps running his business as the chairman of the board but he has people that oversee the day-to-day stuff. Then he just goes and does the fun stuff that he wants to do. I think that’s a pretty good path for me.

How has entrepreneurship changed your life?

We have way more money so we get to do a lot of fun stuff. We get to go on a lot of trips and do a lot of fun things. We still live in the same house we’ve lived in for the last 12 years. We never went and bought a giant mansion because I don’t really want my kids to live some crazy life where it’s just not realistic for them. We live in a 3,000 square foot house. I walk my kids to school every morning and I’m trying to give them kind of a normal childhood. Other than when we go on vacation, we take a private jet, day-to-day it’s very similar to what the people down the street do.

Is there an amount for which you would consider selling MarketBeat?

Every business has a price, right? I think if somebody said here’s $200 million for MarketBeat today, I’d probably have a hard time turning that down. But I don’t know, I like what I’m doing. Whenever somebody emails me and says hey I want to buy your business, we just tell them it’s not for sale because if they’re really serious they’ll just come back and offer a stupid amount of money. Only one person has really done that and it wasn’t the right number.

Matt Paulson Business Stats

Matt Paulson has built MarketBeat into an incredibly profitable email marketing business with impressive financial metrics and operational efficiency. The company generates substantial revenue with a small team, demonstrating the power of audience building and effective monetization in the financial media space.

  • Annual Revenue: $40 million
  • Net Profit: $14 million per year
  • Team Size: 16 employees
  • Revenue Per Employee: $2.3 million annually
  • Email Subscribers: 4.6 million
  • SMS Subscribers: 125,000
  • Web Push Subscribers: 500,000
  • Daily Website Visitors: 300,000-400,000
MetricValue
Started Year2006
Monthly Revenue$3.3 million
Yearly Revenue$40 million
Net Profit Margin35%
Advertising Spend$1.3 million/month

Matt Paulson Method

Matt Paulson’s success with MarketBeat can be attributed to several key strategies and methods that he implemented over the years. His approach focuses on long-term value creation, audience building, and strategic reinvestment.

  • Focus on evergreen content in the financial niche that attracts organic traffic through search engines
  • Build and maintain a massive email list as the primary distribution channel
  • Reinvest approximately one-third of revenue into advertising to continue growing the subscriber base
  • Diversify revenue streams through advertising, subscriptions, and content syndication
  • Automate content creation by transforming SEC filings into financial news stories
  • Stay consistent and focus on the same business for an extended period (15+ years)

Matt Paulson Tools

Matt leverages various tools and technologies to power MarketBeat’s operations and maintain its competitive edge in the financial media space. His tool stack focuses on efficiency, scalability, and long-term reliability.

  • SendGrid – Used for email delivery since 2009, providing reliable infrastructure for sending emails to millions of subscribers
  • Twilio – Utilized for SMS messaging for the past 9 years to reach subscribers via text messages
  • ConvertKit – Matt’s preferred email service provider for his personal brand and newsletter
  • Custom CMS – Proprietary content management system developed specifically for MarketBeat’s needs
  • Multiple Web Servers – Scaled from one to four or five servers to handle traffic spikes during events like the GameStop frenzy

Key Notes

Throughout the interview with Matt Paulson, several key insights emerged about building a successful profitable email marketing business. These notes highlight the most important takeaways from Matt’s experience growing MarketBeat.

  • Distribution is more important than product – having a large audience (4.6 million email subscribers) is MarketBeat’s true competitive advantage
  • Build your audience on platforms others are ignoring – Matt focused on email rather than just social media or SEO
  • Email is the best channel for audience building – it’s stable, owned by no single company, and allows direct communication
  • Consistency over time leads to outsized success – working on the same business for 15+ years has been crucial to Matt’s achievements
  • Reinvest profits strategically – Matt puts about a third of revenue back into advertising to maintain growth

Get Started in Just 5 Steps

Based on Matt Paulson’s experience building MarketBeat into a profitable email marketing business, here are five key steps you can follow to start your own successful audience-building venture.

  • Choose a niche with high profit potential and audience demand – Matt chose financial content because it attracts advertisers with deep pockets
  • Create valuable content that solves problems or provides insights – Matt focused on stock analysis and financial news that investors needed
  • Build an email list from day one with compelling lead magnets – Offer something valuable in exchange for email addresses to grow your audience
  • Develop multiple revenue streams – Matt uses advertising, subscriptions, and syndication to diversify income
  • Reinvest profits systematically into growth – Matt allocates about a third of revenue to advertising to continuously expand his subscriber base

Conclusion

Matt Paulson’s journey with MarketBeat demonstrates the incredible potential of building a profitable email marketing business. By focusing on audience growth, maintaining consistency over 15+ years, and strategically reinvesting profits, Matt has created a business that generates $14 million in net profit annually with just 16 employees. His emphasis on email as a primary distribution channel, combined with valuable financial content and multiple revenue streams, has created a resilient and highly profitable enterprise. Aspiring entrepreneurs can learn from Matt’s approach to building an audience first, then monetizing through diverse channels while maintaining operational efficiency.