Leaving Corporate to Buy a $4.8m Manufacturing Business | Michael Dey Success Story

Introduction

Many professionals dream of leaving the corporate world behind to become business owners, but few take the leap as successfully as Michael Dey. After a 16-year career at Boeing designing cockpits for commercial airplanes, Michael transitioned from corporate executive to manufacturing business owner when he acquired American Spray Technologies for $4.8 million. In this interview, Michael shares his journey, the framework that helped him evaluate the business, and how he managed the risks of such a significant career change.

Founder Success Story QnA

Can you share your background before pursuing business acquisition?

Sure, I grew up in the Houston area and was always mechanically and mathematically inclined. I pursued aerospace engineering at the University of Colorado in Boulder and was hired right out of school by Boeing. I spent my entire post-college life in Seattle, working for Boeing on two different stints totaling about 16 years. My initial role was designing cockpits and flight instruments for commercial airplanes, which was essentially my dream job coming out of engineering school.

What led you to consider leaving corporate for business ownership?

Several factors converged to push me toward this decision. Aerospace is a very cyclical industry, and after being laid off during a downturn, I realized that big companies don’t always protect their employees. Later in my career, while managing engineering teams and transitioning into corporate strategy, I found myself increasingly dissatisfied with the corporate bureaucracy, endless meetings, and the trade-offs required for senior leadership positions. While the compensation was good, money was no longer a major motivator.

How did you discover search funds and business acquisition?

I was pursuing a hybrid MBA program at Rice University’s Jones School while working full-time. It was during this program that I was introduced to the concept of search funds and business acquisition. The timing was interesting – I started school in January 2019, and my second year coincided with COVID when Boeing was facing significant challenges with the 737 Max crisis and industry downturns. The concept of search fund acquisition really grabbed my attention as it offered a different path forward.

What was your initial reaction to the search fund concept?

I had never considered entrepreneurship or business ownership as part of my career path. I knew I didn’t have the “fire in the belly” to start something from scratch, and I didn’t have an earth-shattering business idea. The concept of buying an existing business rather than starting one from scratch was completely new to me. It seemed like a more structured way to transition from corporate life to ownership.

What attracted you to business acquisition specifically?

Several key factors made this path appealing. First was control over my time and flexibility to do what I wanted, which was probably the biggest appeal. My wife and I had gone through a health scare a few years prior that served as a wake-up call to make life happen on our terms. Second was the financial aspect – the return potential from a small business acquisition was significantly better than real estate investments. The framework I learned in my MBA program suggested a minimum 20% return on equity, which was much more attractive than other investment alternatives.

How did you approach your initial exploration of search funds?

During a vacation from my corporate job, I decided to apply myself fully to the search fund coursework as if I were actually conducting a search. I immediately began networking with brokers in the Northwest who handle business sales and started exploring available businesses on platforms like BizBuySell. The experience was energizing – seeing the variety of businesses available, from obvious ones like restaurants to niche manufacturing companies, opened my eyes to possibilities I hadn’t considered before.

What criteria did you establish for your search?

I established several key criteria. First was geographic – I wanted to stay in the Seattle area we love, so my search region extended from Portland, Oregon to the Canadian border. Second, unlike many searchers, I wasn’t interested in service businesses, SaaS, or anything virtual. As an engineer with a love for mechanical things, I specifically wanted a manufacturing business that produced physical products. I was drawn to the idea of manufacturing physical products that could be “made in America” that I could really get my hands into.

How did your wife react to your plans to leave corporate?

My wife was very supportive. We have a great partnership in that regard. For many years, she had taken the riskier career path, working in advertising and then startups, while I maintained the stable corporate job with benefits. By the time I was considering this move, she had a more stable position, so she felt it was my turn to take on some risk. We had financial conversations to ensure we were comfortable with the decision, and she was excited about the potential lifestyle flexibility that business ownership could provide.

What were the key businesses you considered before settling on American Spray Technologies?

I narrowed my search to three realistic candidates. The first was a business that made specialized instruments, but I eliminated it due to keyman risk – the seller was a PhD who was the face of the business, and I couldn’t see a way to fully replace him. The second was a boat repair shop that sold small boats and engines – tempting given my love for boating, but I eliminated it because it wasn’t generating enough cash flow and I worried about turning a passion into a job that might eventually be resented. The third was American Spray Technologies, which ultimately became my acquisition.

What is American Spray Technologies and what do they do?

American Spray Technologies is a manufacturer of large industrial pumps that apply thick, heavy materials like drywall texture, fireproofing, and certain types of paint. These are substantial machines sold to commercial contractors, either on trailers or mounted in box trucks. The machines range from 150 to 500 gallons of material capacity and can spray through very long hoses (up to 300 feet in some cases). This allows contractors to efficiently apply materials to multiple homes in new developments with just a crew of one or two people, creating significant labor savings.

What made this business attractive despite its concentration in the construction industry?

Initially, I was concerned about customer concentration in the construction industry, which is why I had eliminated this business early in my search. However, I came back to it for several reasons. First, the construction industry is quite large and diverse. Second, drywall is a ubiquitous material in construction that isn’t going away anytime soon. Third, the business has been around since the mid-1960s and had been owned by the seller for 25 years, suggesting stability. Fourth, I realized that light texture application has become standard in most new construction for smoothing walls before painting, making it a necessary part of the building process.

What was the business’s financial performance when you acquired it?

For the two years prior to the sale, the business was doing approximately $3 million in revenue with about $500,000 in seller’s discretionary earnings (SDE). It had 16 employees (13 full-time and some part-time). Importantly for me, it had a management layer with a general manager who could handle day-to-day operations, which was a key criterion for me since I wanted to be able to work on the business rather than just in it.

Why was $500,000 SDE your “sweet spot” when many others aim for higher?

Looking back, I might have wanted to go bigger knowing what I know now. However, at the time, I was limited in deal size based on my accumulated savings and the investment property we owned. My wife and I had been planning to sell a condo and invest in something like a triplex or quadplex, but I proposed instead using those funds to invest in real estate as part of a business acquisition bundle. This was partially limiting me in deal size without taking on additional investors, which I wanted to avoid to maintain total control.

Can you explain the valuation framework you used at Rice University’s MBA program?

The framework we teach at Rice is a cash flow-based valuation with a risk buildup approach. It starts with free cash flow, which is different than SDE because you have to subtract what it costs to replace the owner. For example, if the owner was working half-time and SDE was $500,000, you might put in $500,000 for that role, leaving you with $450,000. You also subtract capital expenditures needed to keep the business running. Then you do a risk buildup to understand what return you should expect on your investment as an equity investor.

How does the risk buildup approach to valuation work?

The risk buildup approach starts with the idea that small business acquisitions should return at least 20%, which corresponds to about a 5x multiple of free cash flow. Then you assess the business for various risk factors – customer concentration, keyman risk, industry risks, etc. For each risk factor identified, you incrementally increase the required return, which effectively decreases the multiple you should be willing to pay. The riskier the business, the higher your required return and the lower the multiple you should accept. This gives a more tailored valuation than just applying industry-wide multiples.

What was your offer structure for the business?

My initial proposal included a purchase price right around $2 million for the business alone, which would have been about a 4x SDE multiple. The broker indicated this was significantly below what they would accept. However, the business came with real estate that I was also acquiring. By increasing my offer on the real estate component (ultimately paying $2.8 million for it), I was able to meet in the middle on the total package of $4.8 million. This approach made me more comfortable with the overall deal structure and risk profile.

How did the real estate component help manage your risk?

The real estate component provided several risk