Andrew Wilkinson’s Business Acquisition Strategy: How He Built a $240M Holding Company

Introduction

In this interview, Andrew Wilkinson, co-founder of Tiny, shares his business acquisition strategy that has enabled him to build a $240M holding company with over 35 acquisitions. Starting from a simple tech news site in high school, Andrew has mastered the art of identifying, acquiring, and growing profitable internet businesses. His approach focuses on buying what he calls “New Zealand companies” – unsexy, overlooked businesses that generate consistent profits.

Founder Success Story QnA

Who were you in your early and late 20s when building your first businesses and agency, and how would your colleagues and friends describe you?

I think it’s more interesting to go back to my childhood. When I was a kid, my dad was a struggling entrepreneur. He had his own Architecture Firm and money was always tight. So my parents would always fight and there would be a lot of tension in the house around money. From the time I was little, I always thought I need to get money so that everyone will stop fighting and all my problems will go away. For my whole life, I’ve kind of been obsessed with money and making it. I stumbled into business – I always knew I wanted money but I didn’t know that business was the root there. When I was in high school, I started a tech news site. I was just on my computer one day and I met two kids in a chat room and we decided to start an Apple technology news site. It started doing really well and I started selling advertising on the website and making thousands of a month, which when you’re in grade 10 is a big deal.

What was your journey from dropping out of journalism school to building your agency?

When I was about 18, I went to my dad and I said Dad I’m not going to go to university. I remember we were driving in the car and he slammed the brakes on the car, pointed at a gas station and told me that I’d be working there for the rest of my life. We duked it out and he said ‘look you’re doing this journalism stuff why don’t you go to journalism School’ and so I ended up giving up the website to my business partners and moving away to college. When I got to journalism school, I just pretty quickly realized it wasn’t for me. I did not want to go write for a newspaper. This is in 2004, all the newspapers were going out of business and I was feeling very lost. I ended up dropping out and I got a job as a barista to pay my rent. These two guys would come into the coffee shop I worked at all the time and they would just sit there on their laptops. One day I went up to them and asked them what they did for work. They said they’re web designers and they explained how they go into local businesses and see if they have websites. A lot of small businesses didn’t have websites this is in 2005. That sounded pretty easy, something I could do. I bought a book on web design and walked into a pulled pork barbecue joint. The guy said he’d pay me 500 bucks to make a website.

How did you transition from running an agency to acquiring businesses?

When I started making serious money, I didn’t really know what to do with it. People would tell me I needed to invest in real estate and stocks but to me that was something for guys in suits, not something I was interested in or understood. So I just started a bunch of businesses. Every time I’d have a business idea, I would just start it without thinking about it. I wouldn’t do any analysis. I started a skincare company, a pizzeria, an online DJ school, a designer cat furniture store – you name it, I’ve started a lot of dumb businesses. That was really good training. Buffett has this great quote: ‘I’m a better investor because I’m a businessman and I’m a better businessman because I’m an investor.’ I think that was my time to really recognize the power of a high-quality business and a good business model versus a bad business model. Unfortunately, I did it by learning the hard way and starting all these businesses. I did that for about six or seven years and got to a point where I was the CEO of like six companies at the same time. My time was totally fractured. I wasn’t doing a good job across any of them and I was really unhappy. I realized that I couldn’t just keep starting more and more businesses – that wasn’t going to scale. I took a bit of a breath and decided I would learn about investing. I’d always heard about Warren Buffett but didn’t really know anything about him. I read ‘The Warren Buffett Way’ and was blown away by this concept that not only can you delegate work to your employees, but you can actually delegate the operations of a company to a CEO. That was something I hadn’t ever realized. I’d always thought that I had to be the CEO. As soon as I got out of the CEO seat and started hiring great CEOs and incentivizing them well, all the businesses started doing way better. I realized that like Buffett, I wanted to go buy businesses instead of starting them.

When did you realize it’s better to buy and build businesses with great CEOs versus focusing on one business?

I think it’s not always better to buy a business than to start one, but it depends on your skill set. If I traveled back in time today and gone to my 18-year-old self and said don’t start businesses, just buy them, I think I would have been an incompetent buyer because I didn’t know what a good business was and I didn’t know what a bad business was. It was really important that I had that time in the wilderness failing and starting different businesses and learning different business models because it gave me an eye for what a good business looked like when I was buying them. People have to go and get those reps and experience. One of the problems with a lot of investors in private equity is that they’ve only ever been taught that a business is a spreadsheet. A business is not a spreadsheet – a business is a group of people, and people are incredibly complicated. It’s systems, competitive forces – there’s a lot of nuance to a business. It’s important that people go and get that experience. While it is easy to buy a business once you have experience, it’s not easy to buy a business if you have no experience because you’ll buy a bad business.

What were your first few acquisitions and can you share about their structure and financing?

The very first one that we did was a business called We Work Remotely. It was a job board that was started by Jason and David, the guys that run Basecamp. They had written a book called ‘Remote: Office Not Required’ and as part of that book launch, they had started weworkremotely.com, which was a job board for companies that hired remote workers. I had used it to hire people and was familiar with it. I’m friends with Jason and he just texted me one day and said hey, I don’t know what to do with this job board, we’re too busy running Basecamp. Base Camp is like a $100 million recurring revenue software business and they had this little tiny job board that was making about $500,000 of revenue per year but was highly profitable. They barely touched it and almost every dollar was basically profit. He said look, would you want to buy this thing? He wanted $1.5 million. I looked at it and saw that they hadn’t increased pricing and kept up with other job boards. They were charging $1.99 per job posting but a lot of other job boards were charging $2.99. They weren’t doing any marketing or SEO optimization. I looked at it and thought worst case I pay myself back in three years, best case I can come in, pull a bunch of levers, improve the SEO, improve the pricing. That’s what happened. We ended up buying it for 1.5 million of cash because we were quite cash-rich at the time. We made all those improvements and a couple years ago that business made $4 million of profit in one year. It’s been an incredible acquisition for us.

How do you stay focused on internet businesses when there are opportunities in other industries?

When I read about Warren Buffett, I got excited about traditional businesses. Chris and I started looking at everything from fence rental companies to portapotty businesses to crematoriums, gravel pits – all sorts of different businesses. Over and over again, we would meet with these founders and they would tell us huge revenue numbers that blew our minds. They’d say we do $100 million of revenue and Chris and I would be going oh my God, like we only do 15, this is going to be a huge business. Then we would look at their profit and loss statement and see that at the end of the day, they’d maybe make 1 or 2 million of profit. Often the profit had to go back into the business to buy more trucks or do capex. Pretty quickly we realized that oh wow, these internet businesses are pretty awesome. If you have a million dollars of profit, that’s probably at least $700,000 of cash in your jeans at the end of the year if you want it to be. We started really focusing back on internet businesses and realized that we had an unfair advantage – that was our expertise, what we knew how to optimize. Our network was in tech, so when we bought businesses, we knew the founders, we had a reputation in the tech world, and we knew great operators. If we went and bought brick and mortar businesses, we didn’t know anyone in that world – we were kind of the patsy at the poker table.

After your first acquisition, how did you approach the next deals?

We kind of have long periods of doing nothing and then sudden moments of activity. Maybe 6 to 12 months later, we bought Dribbble, which is a large social network for graphic and web designers. I had actually used Dribbble for years to hire designers and find work for my agency, so I was very familiar with it. The co-founder, Dan Cedarholm, had actually written the book on web design that I had learned from, so I was kind of obsessed with him. I just started calling him up and asking if he would sell. Every 3 or 4 months I’d send him an email and say hey, has anything changed? I just wanted to check in, no pressure but if you ever want to sell. I stayed on his radar and one day he just called me up and said hey, can you fly to Boston, I want to meet with you. Chris and I flew to Boston and negotiated a deal to buy that business. That was one that was much more Buffett-esque. With We Work Remotely, we were buying a pretty high-quality business, but there’s really no moat in job boards. If you have job board A and job board B, there’s not really any reason why someone would post on your job board versus LinkedIn or whatever. It’s kind of a commodity, so it was a cheap business for a reason. With Dribbble, it had what I would call a network effect moat. In the same way that you don’t want to go on an alternative to Instagram because all your friends are on Instagram, it had a competitive moat. There wasn’t really a lot of competition – there was one other social network and it had been acquired by a large public company and wasn’t really evolving. We paid up for that one – we were really scared. We paid about 10 times earnings to buy that business and felt that if somebody raised a billion dollars of venture capital and decided to compete with it, it would still be hard. We felt comfortable paying up because we were getting something unique.

How do you develop the patience to wait for the right deals?

Usually when we talk to people and over and over again they say crazy numbers. It’s not that we don’t get deal flow and see opportunities – we see businesses that we love. The problem is that the founder is not usually willing to sell at a rational price. In 2020 when the stock market was crazy and venture capitalists were giving every company under the sun billion dollar valuations, we would have someone with a $2 million revenue business say they wanted $100 million for it. There was just no way to productively engage in deal making at that point. Usually when we have a period like that, we just kind of cool it for a while.

What do you mean by “New Zealand companies”?

New Zealand is an interesting country in that it’s in the middle of nowhere, no one’s paying attention to it, but it’s quietly successful. Because it’s in the middle of nowhere, it’s also not at risk of nuclear war – it’s totally self-sufficient, food and energy independent. If we adapt that to business, we want a business that is not sexy, that not a lot of other people are looking at. We want that because those are the opportunities to pay a fair price. If everyone is looking at something, you’re getting an extreme price typically, an inflated price. It’s also something that venture capital is not paying attention to, which is good because if you have a business where venture capital is excited about the space, they will go fund your competition very aggressively. I actually like businesses that are not billion dollar rocket ships because if you have a billion dollar rocket ship, the VCs go oh cool, like those guys made a billion dollars, we should go and fund 10 more competitors. We also want something that’s kind of food and energy independent like New Zealand – something that isn’t beholden to Google or Facebook or something like that to reach its customer. In the case of Dribbble, a lot of the traffic was just people going to dribbble.com in their URL bar. It wasn’t people searching how do I hire a web designer and then ending up at Dribbble. So Google couldn’t disintermediate us or we’re not reliant on a YouTube channel or an algorithm. Then also just profitability creates independence. We’re always looking for businesses that are totally profitable, don’t need to raise additional capital.

How do you find companies to acquire when there are smart people chasing the same deals?

This assumes an efficient market, and this is something that a lot of investors don’t understand. Ultimately these decisions are very emotional. Speaking from my experience, when I started my business, I couldn’t imagine selling it. If you told me that I should sell my business, it would be the equivalent of saying you should sell your baby for liquor money – it’s unthinkable. But once I was five, six, seven, eight years in, I was really exhausted. I didn’t know how to grow it, I got to a certain point, a certain scale, and I was tapped out. If someone had come along at that point and said hey, you can cash out and do something different, I’ll make it really easy on you, I’ll give you all cash up front, I won’t waste your time and do crazy diligence or make it into a six to eight month process, I’m not going to lever up your company, I’ll treat your staff right, and I have a reputation for doing so for leaving people alone – people are willing to sell at a reasonable price. The most staggering statistic is that most successful small businesses are not sold, they’re shut down. They just close the door and close the bank account. If that was an efficient market, that would never happen. It all comes down to relationships and reputation and figuring out psychology and what do people actually want. When I talk to a founder, I don’t start by saying what kind of EBIT multiple do you want. I ask them what are your biggest problems in the business, what’s stressing you out, what do you want in your personal life, what does money mean to you, do you want to buy a house, do you want to buy a Lamborghini or do you want to have just a stock portfolio. I try and engage them in those questions and then I can design a deal around that.

What do you typically do in the first 90 days after an acquisition?

Most of the work is actually before we buy the business. We generally will not buy the business unless we have a CEO who we really like who can take the reins. The biggest mistakes we’ve made have been buying businesses and not having a clear leader on day one where we’re like oh, we’ll hire someone in the next 6 months, and it just languishes. When we know we’re going to buy a business, we immediately start a recruiting process. I’m looking for somebody who’s run a similar business, same or similar business, double the size, and who has a strategy that I agree with and that I get a good feeling from. When I meet them, I want them to come in and say oh, I remember I joined this other company that’s similar to this one when it was half the size, here’s the playbook I used to grow it to the size it’s at now. I want to be nodding along and going oh yeah, okay, like perfect – pricing, SEO, marketing. I want to agree with what they want to do, and then I want to leave with a good feeling from that person. I’ve learned the hard way that there’s a lot of really smart executives and CEOs, but if they’re not a great person that I want to spend time with, it will not go well, either because maybe they’ll be unethical or just not enjoyable to spend time with.

How do you incentivize CEOs in your acquired businesses?

We’ve done a variety of different things and experimented. What we’ve found works the best is a base salary that makes them comfortable. So let’s say that to have a nice house in the neighborhood they’re in and send their kids to private school, they need a $250,000 salary. We will give them a base salary that just meets those needs, nothing more ideally, and then we’ll have the rest as a bonus or equity. We love to tie a bonus to a profit target or some kind of metric like return on invested capital. If we bought the business for $10 million and the business earns $3 million in this year, that’s a 30% return on invested capital, and great, you’re going to hit a bonus of XYZ. If a CEO says I need to own equity, we’ll usually say okay, well your total compensation between base and bonus would be about $500,000. How much of that do you want to take away and put into buying equity? I like that because they actually care about the equity, whereas if they get stock options, they usually don’t value it as part of their total compensation. They look at it as a lottery ticket, but it’s extremely expensive for shareholders. In a private business, there’s no stock market ticker, so it’s very fuzzy. I much prefer to just bonus people large amounts of money.

What are your strengths and weaknesses compared to your partner Chris?

If we owned buildings and we weren’t business partners, if I owned a building, it would be architecturally beautiful, incredibly well-designed, shiny and amazing. People would love living there and there’d be a lot of pride for me owning it, but it wouldn’t make as much money. It would probably not be very profitable because I’m a designer and I love everything to be well thought out and well organized. I will spend additional money to make sure it’s exceptional. Chris would own a horrible derelict building that was almost embarrassing. He wouldn’t want to say he owned it, and the people who live there would just get enough that they wouldn’t move out. He’s very cheap. You put those two things together and you get something really special where I want to go and say yes to everything and grow, and I want to make everything perfect. Chris wants to dial everything back and get it hyper profitable. Those two things balance each other out really interestingly. Over time, we’ve both come to see the validity of one another’s perspectives.

How many companies have you acquired and do you ever sell them?

We’re at about 30 or so acquisitions, maybe more. Very rarely do we sell a company. We’ve sold one company and we bought it back. Then we have sold a few small businesses. Occasionally we’ll buy something that is too small for us and we thought we could grow it, and we aren’t able to, so we’ll sell those businesses usually if they’re a distraction. We haven’t had any that we’ve fully closed down. We bought one business called Designer News and we thought it would be a great addition to Dribbble, but we realized that Reddit kind of destroyed it. Everyone just started posting on Reddit and nobody wanted to use this special website, so we shut that one down, but that’s quite rare for us. We’re not taking a lot of risk when we buy businesses – we’re generally buying businesses that will continue to exist.

How connected are the businesses in your portfolio?

Our style has been to be very decentralized. We have generally not had the companies interact in any way. It’s very tempting when you own a conglomerate to start saying let’s synergize in all these different ways because we can save money and have shared services, but in practice it’s been something that has generally not worked for Chris and me. Chris and I stepped down as COO and we put Jordan to in charge. He worked at Constellation Software for years and has found some opportunities to synergize finance teams, a little bit of recruiting. I’d say it’s shifting over time. Chris and I were very adamant about never having the companies interact in any forced way. We’d always say if the companies naturally partner, that’s fine, but we’re not going to push them together. Jordan may have a different approach to that, but usually we try and follow the Berkshire model of just leaving things to do their thing.

You tweeted that small things get big – can you elaborate on that?

A lot of people miss in tech that small things get big. Some of our best acquisitions, businesses that currently produce large amounts of cash flow in our public company, started out as 1 to 10 million investments. Compounding happens fast in digital businesses. Way too many people dismiss the fast-growing or neglected the 500k EBITA business. The story I shared earlier about We Work Remotely or Dribbble – those were both relatively small businesses. One was a $10 million acquisition, the other was a $1.5 million acquisition, and in both cases, those have grown very significantly. It’s easy to dismiss those businesses because they seem small. If you have a mental model that comes from the brick and mortar world, it’s very difficult to take a 500K brick and mortar business and scale it in four years to something that is doing $3 million of EBIT, because the nature of the physical world is you can’t build a facility quickly or hire people. With digital businesses, if you identify a business that’s under-monetized or where there are levers, you can basically grow it infinitely within 6 to 12 months.

You mentioned that psychology is 70% of business – can you elaborate on that?

I often joke that Chris and I are like therapists. We’ve gotten really good at mirroring people. Someone tells you a problem and you say it back in a way that shows that you understand with empathy, not pushing your ideas on somebody, using questioning to lead them down a path. Those are basic psychology things that are incredibly helpful. Businesses are not spreadsheets – they’re groups of people. If you’re not good with people, you’re not going to be successful in business. Being able to go into a meeting and say hey, there’s a problem and we should solve it in this way, and then being able to read someone’s face and say that CEO is not on board – because they’re not on board, they’re not going to execute on what we want. On the flip side, having a very good spidey sense for what types of people will be difficult to work with is very important. We’ve had experiences where we’ve worked with people who are highly emotional, paranoid, narcissistic, psychopathic. We just want to avoid dealing with high conflict people in general. Being able to flag those traits when you see them is a little bit like when you go on a first date with somebody and they’re rude to the waiter. You go I’m not going to date this person, even though it’s just this tiny little thing. I know what that leads to, I know what that most likely indicates about their personality. That same thing applies in business.

You’ve said that selling to price-sensitive customers is a nightmare – can you elaborate?

One of the worst kinds of businesses is one that sells something to a price-sensitive customer. My nightmare business is a software company that creates software for school teachers to help them manage their class schedules. The easiest types of businesses are when you sell something that wealthy people or to companies actually want and it solves a simple problem. If you think about it, I’d much rather have a simple software product that’s like a basic widget. You could build a calendar scheduling widget right now – it’s pretty easy to build, cheap to operate. If you sell it to businesses, you can charge $100 a month. If you sell it to school teachers, you can charge $2 a month. Which of those customers do you want? Which sticks around longer? Which complains less and has less support burden? Not enough young entrepreneurs think about that. It’s often easy to just pivot your idea slightly and sell it to a different customer.

How do you follow Charlie Munger’s advice to “always take the high road”?

Life is so much better and you’ll be more successful if you have a good reputation. A lot of the reason why people sell to us is because we have a good reputation for not ruining companies or treating people badly or screwing people out of deals based on little terms. One of the simple things we do is sometimes if we look at buying a business and the founder spends a lot of time going back and forth with us and then we pass, we’ll just pay their legal fees. We paid $50,000, $100,000 of legal fees for someone. They were annoyed because we backed out of the deal, but it was this little thing that we did to just be nice. Going that extra mile to make sure that you leave people with a positive impression of you goes a very long way. It probably took that person from saying I hate those guys, they wasted my time, to you know what, we didn’t do a deal together but they were good guys, they took care of me in the end. There are opportunities in business to take advantage of certain situations – you can price gouge. I recently downloaded an app on the App Store and it’s like a competitive app to something that we own. When you sign up, it says free trial but then it renews at a crazy price and bills you insane amounts. I just go like I don’t want to make money that way. Would that make me rich faster? Yes, but I don’t want to be known for that. Warren Buffett is able to buy the world’s best businesses because of his incredible reputation. Protecting your reputation is everything.

What have you learned from Jason Fried’s philosophy on simplicity in business?

The whole reason that I got into business and starting software companies was just watching Jason and David build their business. I was always so jealous of them and I still am. Jason more than any other entrepreneur is so good at only doing things that he wants to do intrinsically. If you look at how he runs his company, he has created this very strange, unique culture where it perfectly matches his personality and the products reflect him. At no point has he ever taken the low road. He never does something because it makes business sense – he does things because it’s the right thing to do for the customer and because he and David want to do that thing. The way that they’ve gone about building their business is just incredibly unique and inspiring. Jason has really stuck to his guns and just done his own thing. All these other people who came up around the same time may have gone off and become billionaires and had public companies, but I just don’t think they’re as happy as he is. He’s got the world’s best business for his specific personality.

Why do you advise against giving away equity for free?

People don’t quite understand that equity is forever. If I give you 1% equity, every time I earn a dollar, you’re getting one cent for the forever. That’s a lot to give up, and you may only be involved in the business for 3 years, but the business might go on for 30 years. Do I really want to give up one cent of every dollar for the next 30 years because you were involved in the business for 3 years? Sometimes it makes a ton of sense – the business wouldn’t have started without you or something like that. But it’s a big ask, so I just like to make it a very serious conversation where if somebody wants equity, they have to come to the table with me and fight for it and buy in.

What are you consuming today to learn and stay on top?

I’ve stopped reading the news. I mostly read business biographies and I love the Founders podcast by David Senra. All he does is he does a one to two hour deep dive on a book that he’s read that week, usually business or interesting public figure memoirs, usually of people who are at the end of their career or are already dead. You can learn so much more by seeing someone’s full arc. It’s like looking at a stock ticker – if you see someone at a moment where they’re up, you don’t know if they’re going to go back down. Reading a memoir is interesting because you can really see that person was a crazy entrepreneur, but then when they were old, they had no loved ones and their kids hated them, or they ended up losing all their money. It’s interesting to learn from someone’s full life.

Andrew Wilkinson Business Stats

Andrew Wilkinson has built an impressive portfolio through his business acquisition strategy. His holding company, Tiny, has acquired over 35 businesses with a combined valuation of $240 million. His approach focuses on identifying profitable, simple internet businesses that others overlook.

  • Age: 38 years old
  • Number of businesses acquired: 35+
  • Holding company valuation: $240M
  • First acquisition: We Work Remotely for $1.5M
  • Second major acquisition: Dribbble for $10M
  • Annual profit from We Work Remotely: $4M
AcquisitionInitial InvestmentCurrent Annual ProfitROI Timeline
We Work Remotely$1.5M$4MUnder 2 years
Dribbble$10MSignificant portion of $240M valuation5-6 years

Andrew Wilkinson Method

Andrew’s business acquisition strategy follows a systematic approach that has proven successful across dozens of acquisitions. His method focuses on identifying the right type of businesses and ensuring proper management post-acquisition.

  • Target “New Zealand companies” – unsexy, overlooked, profitable internet businesses
  • Look for businesses with competitive moats that aren’t reliant on Google or Facebook
  • Focus on companies that are already profitable and don’t need additional capital
  • Recruit a great CEO before finalizing any acquisition
  • Incentivize CEOs with performance-based bonuses rather than just salary
  • Leave businesses to operate independently without forced synergies

Andrew Wilkinson Tools

While Andrew doesn’t extensively discuss specific tools in this interview, his approach to business relies on several key resources and methodologies that support his business acquisition strategy.

  • Financial analysis tools for evaluating potential acquisitions and their profit potential
  • Relationship management to maintain his reputation and network in the tech industry
  • Due diligence processes to thoroughly evaluate businesses before acquisition
  • Performance metrics like return on invested capital to measure success
  • Biographies and podcasts like Founders by David Senra for continuous learning

Key Notes

Andrew Wilkinson’s success with his business acquisition strategy offers several important lessons for entrepreneurs and investors looking to build a portfolio of companies.

  • Business is 70% psychology – learning to read people is crucial for success
  • It’s easier to go from 3 to 10 than from 0 to 1 – improving existing businesses is often simpler than starting from scratch
  • Reputation is everything in deal-making – taking the high road leads to more opportunities
  • Avoid high-conflict people – they drain energy and rarely lead to positive outcomes
  • Small digital businesses can compound quickly – don’t overlook opportunities that seem minor initially

Get Started in Just 5 Steps

If you want to implement a similar business acquisition strategy to Andrew Wilkinson’s, here are five key steps to get started on your journey of building a portfolio of businesses.

  • Gain operational experience by starting and running your own business first – this helps you understand what makes a good business
  • Study successful investors like Warren Buffett to understand the principles of acquiring and holding businesses
  • Build your reputation and network in your target industry so that deal flow comes to you
  • Develop a framework for evaluating businesses that focuses on profitability, competitive advantages, and management potential
  • Start small with your first acquisition to learn the process before tackling larger deals

Conclusion

Andrew Wilkinson’s business acquisition strategy offers a compelling alternative to the traditional startup path. By focusing on acquiring profitable, simple internet businesses that others overlook, he has built a $240M holding company by age 38. His approach emphasizes the importance of reputation, understanding people, and patience in waiting for the right deals. For entrepreneurs who may not want to start businesses from scratch or who excel at improving existing operations, Wilkinson’s method provides a proven framework for building a portfolio of valuable companies.