Introduction
Learn from Alex Mears, former executive at Blackstone and Carlisle, who shares valuable private equity best practices for search funds in this revealing interview. Alex recently launched Brydon Group, a search accelerator with partners Steve Wrestler and George Duteil, bringing big PE expertise to the search fund world.
Founder Success Story QnA
Can you share your background and how you got involved in search funds?
Yeah absolutely. So up until a month and a half ago, it was fairly traditional large cap private equity I would say with one asterisk. Started 20 years ago at Goldman banking, worked at Blackstone in their buyout fund all pre-crisis. Then I had an opportunity to go to business school and go back to Blackstone but decided to take a little bit of a break and instead join the military and foreign service. I was an intelligence officer with the Navy Seals, spent five and a half years in Iraq, Afghanistan, Indonesia. Then my wife gently reminded me it was time to come home, so I came back and then up until just recently was at Carlisle in their U.S. bio fund focused on software, government services and business services.
How did you meet Steve Wrestler and get involved in search funds?
We met originally. Steve’s background, his pre-search career was very successful, multi-time gov tech CEO running government software businesses. That was a space I knew very very well, and candidly the list of outstanding operators is fairly short and his was always at the top. That’s how we originally met. Then we were both fascinated by search. My sort of entree to it, peers of mine launched searches 16 years ago, so I’ve been familiar with it for quite some time. But it was really five or six years ago I started getting outreach from veterans who were going to business school and were interested in either private equity or search. That was how I got initially introduced into it.
What’s your investing track record in search funds to date?
Steve and I together have backed now over 70 searchers, 40 of those are closed transactions, and roughly 30 are actively searching today. Our experience has been very consistent. When you look at industries, we skew probably a little bit more heavily to software and some of the higher end technical services just given my background and Steve’s background. But it’s a microcosm of what you would see if you picked up the Stanford study. I don’t know, 40-45% software, another 30-35% business services, tech services, and then some government services and healthcare services round it out.
What can searchers learn from big private equity about identifying high-quality businesses?
First, especially in small business land, there are a lot of wonderful small businesses but they aren’t necessarily high quality. Those businesses tend to be higher risk because they can disintegrate once the owner leaves, and they can be much harder to scale because they don’t have an overwhelmingly compelling reason to win. A few things we’ve tried to bring from large cap private equity is first understanding at what level the competition is. There are businesses that compete at a local level like home services, janitorial, HVAC. Almost all that competition is just at the local level. Then if you scale up, most software businesses and technical services typically compete at the national scale. Understanding what level of competition you’re at is incredibly important.
How do these private equity principles apply to smaller businesses like plumbing companies or tree services?
When we’re talking about business quality, it’s not to say you can’t make money with these other businesses. It’s more if you’re trying to buy one business that minimizes your downside and has growth opportunity, keep these principles in mind. Even at a local level, take something simple like cleaning services. There are businesses you occasionally see purchased in search, but the barriers to entry are exceptionally low. If you have long-term contracts, even in commercial cleaning, the challenge is it’s really hard to scale and there’s always going to be a margin cap because it’s easy for someone else to come in and offer that exact same service at a lower price. But take a more specialized cleaning service, like for industrial meat packing plants. There are huge regulatory concerns, and if they mess up cleaning, the whole production line could be shut down. That’s incredibly important but the cleaning itself isn’t that expensive relative to the overall cost. That would be an example of a business with more defensible characteristics.
Does buying a more specialized business make it harder for a searcher without industry experience to establish credibility with the seller?
I agree. I think certainly for more technical businesses, the expectation would be that the searcher would have more technical background. One thing we recommend to our searchers is to use their backgrounds to their advantage. The types of businesses they look at – we’re huge advocates of industry-focused search for this reason. If a searcher worked for a truck manufacturer pre-business school, they have more credibility talking with anyone in the auto/truck ecosystem just because they’ve got a brand they can reference. The other thing is, about a quarter of the deals we’ve worked on are with veterans taking advantage of that background. If an owner was in the military or service, being able to show commonality with the owners is incredibly important and counts for more than having the perfected email campaign. Being able to leverage your own background to explain why you’re a good home for that seller’s life work is crucial.
How does the emotional aspect of search fund deals differ from private equity acquisitions?
Yeah absolutely. Even in private equity, a buyer will try to differentiate based on how well they’re going to take care of the business, but financial considerations often prevail. With searchers, especially for higher-quality businesses, those businesses are attractive to private equity. The value prop the searcher provides is that it’s a different model – they may be taking institutional dollars to fund it, but they’ll be stepping into the CEO role and managing “your baby” that you created and grew. When we’re working with searchers, that’s something we tell them to be proud of – that is the value prop. Especially in a proprietary deal, you need to have that personal resonance for the transaction to work.
How important is seller integrity in search fund deals?
That’s how important this is. It goes to the nature of a transaction – there’s such information asymmetry. You can spend millions on diligence, but there will always be information asymmetry between what the existing owner knows and what you know. One thing we always recommend is doing a cheap background check quickly to make sure there aren’t lawsuits or other issues. If a business seller has not treated customers, employees, former employees, or former business partners ethically, I can promise you when selling a business, you’re in for trouble. That’s worth terms of EBITDA – it’s so massively impactful in terms of outcome and minimizing downside. As you get further into diligence, talking to customers and employees with that lens, trying to get a sense of whether what’s said is consistent with what’s done – that’s a simple measure of integrity.
How common is lack of seller integrity in your experience?
Not a majority of the time, but candidly, you will often know if this is someone of high integrity. It impacts how I build a model or support a searcher building a model. If I have absolute confidence that what he or she says is real and true, I’m willing to pay more for that business, full stop. I’m a huge advocate of search, but one of the things as search has exploded is sometimes there can be a lack of focus on the downside. We’ve seen examples of blatant regulatory violations that threaten the entire business. In those cases, the searcher says, “This guy’s kind of not on the up and up, but I’m getting it for super cheap.” Life’s too short. The searcher is only doing one deal. There are millions of small businesses in this country, but only thousands of great ones. Just go find a great one. Part of being great is having a seller you can trust when they sell the business.
Is it better to pay more for a business with high integrity than get a discount on one with questionable integrity?
As far as I’m concerned, it’s binary. Sometimes people say they want to do a distressed deal and buy it for two and a half times EBITDA. The math in search where you’re paying four to eight times EBITDA is such that as long as you buy a good business and do well, that’s a great outcome. There’s no reason to take the massive upside risk of a seller who’s clearly not a good person with issues at the business just for the sake of a turn or two of EBITDA. That’s true in private equity and even more true in these businesses because a fundamental flaw is they’re so owner-driven. I would argue a majority of small businesses in America can’t or shouldn’t be sold because they’re effectively jobs of the owner. Those personal relationships don’t transfer, so when you have a business that’s not institutionalized, which describes pretty much every search business, that matters even more in terms of your assessment.
What have you learned about key employees when acquiring businesses?
I’ve seen this over and over again. The employee question – oftentimes what you’ll see is sellers understandably don’t want to introduce prospective buyers to employees until they know it’s an absolute done deal. But in situations where a searcher wasn’t permitted to speak to any employees until a deal was effectively signed, almost universally ends up with some issue. We’ve seen employees who were promised large raises but it’s not documented, so you’re stepping into a different cost basis. Or employees who’ve said they’re leaving and are critical. In diligence, it’s really important to map what each person in that business does, what their value prop is, where their relationships are. You might find there’s one business development person with relationships with the top three customers, and it’s all personal. You better know going in that sales person is on board and eager to continue, because if they leave and take those customers, that’s devastating.
When should searchers ask to meet key employees during the acquisition process?
I always say before signing. There’s often that period where you’ve effectively agreed on all terms, then you basically say, “Before I sign this agreement, I need to meet X, Y, and Z, and I need to do so in an unchaperoned manner.” It’s fine if the seller is on the call to introduce you, but then you’d like to sit down with the person and have a conversation. Typically we’ve found sellers are fine with that once they know it’s more like a confirmatory diligence item rather than a regular due diligence item. And yes, you should let the seller know in advance. I tend to be upfront and candid in communication with sellers so there are absolutely no surprises. If a seller up front tells you you’re not going to be allowed to talk to a single employee or customer before you sign, that’s a really useful data point to have before you spend tens of thousands on diligence.
What other surprises might searchers encounter after acquiring a business?
One we’ve seen a few times is regulatory compliance issues that impact the P&L of the business. Let me give you a real example – providing in-home service care to patients. There’s a contractual level requiring a certain number of people to qualify to a certain level, and those higher qualifications cost more. Sometimes you’ll see, especially a year or two before sale, what I’ll call “greening the workforce” where they bring in cheaper, lower qualified individuals to service. You might get away with that short term and show higher profit, but you’re violating the terms of the contract and potentially the law. When you step in and have to hire the proper level of care, that’s going to hit your profits pretty hard. These are really hard ones because not only are you dealing with historical liabilities, but literally by fixing compliance, your profits are impacted.
How should searchers handle compliance due diligence when they’re unfamiliar with an industry’s regulations?
It is outsourcing. There are specialist consultants who know every variant of potential issues in a sector. It’s the classic searcher dilemma – it looks like a reasonable amount of money for diligence, and you wonder if compliance is really that important. It depends on the business model, but in many cases it is. We have vendors we know who are 100% locked onto the regulations and can quickly identify issues. It’s really hard for a searcher without background in that space to know what those issues are. One area we strongly recommend bringing an outside party to assist with is compliance due diligence. The searcher needs the judgment to say, “Hey, actually this is pretty important for the business, I need outside help.” There’s nothing wrong with that – that’s the right answer.
What led you to formalize your investing into Brydon Group?
The Brydon Group – we do invest, we’ll take minority stakes in traditional searchers in a small number, especially if we feel we can be particularly valuable in their search, like in software or government services. But we also wanted to create what we’re calling an entrepreneur in residence program. With that program, we’ll fund 90% of our entrepreneurial residents’ search both at the search phase and at the deal phase, and provide a lot more support. We’ll pick five a year, they come through as an EIR cohort, they go through training. As we stepped back and thought about building something beyond just personal investing, our view was that the offering had to be much better for searchers. We didn’t want to be another moderately value-added person who takes 10-20% stakes in traditional searches. From our perspective, we wanted to be much more value-add. It’s really hard going and writing small checks into 40 searchers. We’d much rather put all our eggs in one basket and really help that basket.
Is Brydon Group based on the traditional search fund model?
Yeah, so the salary is higher – we support salaries between $150,000 and $200,000 a year at the search level – but then the equity split will be the traditional terms, up to 25%. I would call Brydon Group an accelerator, though it’s more like a hybrid of private equity and search. It is an accelerator in the sense of the percentage we’re backing and providing a lot more support.
How does Brydon Group compare to traditional search fund investors?
In a traditional search fund, searchers go out finding anywhere from 10 to 20 plus investors. There’s an element of that fundraise which some searchers like and some don’t. They build an investor base, get recommendations or templates from investors, then as they find opportunities, they take them back to that group of investors who give thumbs up or down. It’s more of an individual sport. What we’re trying to do is different. Beyond raising that extra 10%, from day one, we have an outsourced team that does data scraping, cleaning up Excel, finding phone numbers, normalizing everything. From day one as an EIR with Brydon, you get your CRM system, recommendations on how to build lists and an outsourced team to help. On the deal side, with a lot of different investors, searchers often don’t get clear thumbs up or down and can spend time on deals that ultimately don’t happen. With us, we sit down with the searcher on every opportunity – yes, let’s run hard at this, or not, or this is such a good business you should pay more for it.
What advantages does the accelerator model provide for deal flow?
Exactly – that engine has value to the searcher. The other big thing not talked about often in search is that most brokers or lower middle market bankers won’t show opportunities to searchers, whether traditional or self-funded. They hear “searcher” and think they don’t have committed capital, so they won’t show them deals. Another advantage for us with Brydon is we have relationships with bankers and brokers, and we can say we are committed capital. If we like a deal, that deal is getting done. It provides the best of both worlds – brokers see committed capital, but it’s not just private equity, there’s an entrepreneur who will take over as CEO and take care of the business through the next phase of growth.
Do searchers need an industry focus or thesis to work with Brydon Group?
The answer is yes, we’re open to both. From our experience and research, thesis-driven searches work better – they end up with better outcomes, higher deal close rates, and higher IRRs post-close. That was a recurring theme when we created Brydon. We want our EIRs aligned with that. They don’t have to come in with an industry thesis, but we encourage it. If someone has spent time in healthcare services and sees an opportunity, great, we’ll fully support that. If not, we want to sit down and come up with several sub-industries where they’ll spend disproportionate time. Knowledge and relationships compound, but they tend to compound by industry. Given our backgrounds in software, there’s a broad range of industries we’re backing searchers in, but we think there’s more value in disproportionate time around industry search versus a complete scatter shot.
Did you always envision yourself becoming an entrepreneur?
I think more the latter – this was such a unique opportunity and feeling like we could build something really special and valuable for searchers was incredibly appealing. It wasn’t like I was looking to be an entrepreneur generally. This was just a tremendous opportunity to work full-time supporting searchers and the community, which was something pretty special for us.
Can people still come to you with deals if they’re not part of Brydon Group?
Yep absolutely. We’ll continue to invest and candidly we do a lot even if it’s not a question of investing – if people want a second set of eyes on a deal, we do that a lot. Some of my personal proudest moments were sitting down with searchers and saying, “You should probably just move on,” helping them avoid a landmine. Steve has done a tremendous job in the community, and we still want to help whether it’s investing, advice, or introductions to other investors. Please reach out, even as a self-funded searcher.
How can people connect with you and learn more about Brydon Group?
Our website is brydon.com (B-R-Y-D-O-N), with more information on the entrepreneur in residence program and application. You can reach out to me at Alexander M-E-A-R-S at brydon.com. I’m on Twitter at @leveredknowledge. Please do reach out if you’re interested in learning more or just to connect on search more broadly.
What’s the timeline for applying to the first Brydon Group cohort?
June 15th is the deadline for applications. We haven’t officially made any offers and aren’t planning to until after that deadline to give everyone time to get applications in. The application is a form on the website, then we receive a call and it goes from there. There’s an interview process and a few assessment tests. Having gone through selection at the Navy Seal team, we’re working with the same person who designed that to help with the testing. It’ll be fun and we’re learning a lot in the process.
Alex Mears Business Stats
Alex Mears brings an impressive background from top private equity firms and military service to his new venture Brydon Group. His experience spans decades of high-level deal making and operational leadership, which he now applies to helping search funds succeed.
- Former executive at Blackstone and Carlisle, two of the world’s largest private equity firms
- Served as intelligence officer with Navy Seals for 5.5 years in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Indonesia
- Backed over 70 searchers with 40 closed transactions to date
- Founded Brydon Group with partners Steve Wrestler and George Duteil
- Selecting 5 entrepreneurs annually for the Brydon Group EIR program
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Years in Private Equity | 20+ |
| Searchers Backed | 70+ |
| Closed Transactions | 40 |
| Active Searchers | 30 |
| Founders | 3 |
Alex Mears Method
Alex applies private equity best practices to search fund investing, focusing on quality businesses, thorough due diligence, and value creation. His method combines institutional rigor with operational expertise to help searchers succeed.
- Evaluate businesses based on competition level – local, regional, national or international
- Assess customer stickiness through criticality and materiality analysis
- Prioritize seller integrity through background checks and consistency verification
- Conduct thorough due diligence on key employees and customer relationships
- Focus on thesis-driven searches for better outcomes and higher IRRs
Alex Mears Tools
Through Brydon Group, Alex provides searchers with specialized tools and resources that streamline the acquisition process and improve due diligence effectiveness, drawing from his private equity experience.
- Pre-built CRM system for managing deal flow and industry research
- Outsourced team for data scraping, contact verification, and list building
- Specialist compliance consultants for industry-specific due diligence
- Access to proprietary deal flow through broker and banker relationships
- Committed capital structure to accelerate deal closing process
Key Notes
The conversation with Alex Mears reveals critical insights for search fund investors looking to apply private equity best practices to their acquisition process. His experience highlights the importance of business quality assessment, thorough due diligence, and ethical seller relationships.
- Business quality assessment should focus on competitive level and customer stickiness
- Seller integrity is paramount – worth paying more for high-integrity sellers
- Always meet key employees before signing any acquisition deal
- Compliance due diligence requires specialized industry expertise
- Thesis-driven searches result in better outcomes than scatter-shot approaches
Get Started in Just 5 Steps
Applying private equity best practices to search fund investing doesn’t require decades of experience. Follow these five steps to improve your acquisition process and outcomes based on Alex Mears’ recommendations.
- Define your industry thesis early to leverage compounding knowledge and relationships
- Establish a rigorous due diligence process including background checks on sellers
- Always meet key employees and major customers before signing purchase agreements
- Invest in specialized compliance due diligence for unfamiliar industries
- Partner with experienced investors who provide committed capital and operational support
Conclusion
Alex Mears’ journey from private equity executive to search fund accelerator founder demonstrates the value of bringing institutional best practices to the search fund world. By focusing on business quality assessment, thorough due diligence, and ethical seller relationships, searchers can significantly improve their acquisition outcomes. Brydon Group represents a new model that combines the capital and expertise of private equity with the hands-on approach of traditional search funds, offering compelling advantages for entrepreneurs looking to acquire and grow small businesses.