How August Felker Built a Multi-Million Dollar Insurance Brokerage from Scratch

Introduction

August Felker, a two-time successful entrepreneur and founder of Overly Risk Strategies, shares his journey of buying and scaling a small insurance brokerage. Learn how he navigated the challenges of purchasing an elevator asset business, building trust with clients, and transitioning leadership while maintaining profitability.

Founder Success Story QnA

What inspired you to start your first search fund?

August Felker: “I was inspired by two close mentors who had successfully used a search fund to buy a logistics business in South San Francisco. Their confidence in me, despite my lack of an MBA, encouraged me to pursue entrepreneurship and led me to explore the search fund model.”

How did you find the Madison insurance brokerage?

August Felker: “I leveraged my network by cold calling, writing handwritten letters, and seeking introductions from editors at industry publications. Persistence and a genuine approach helped me connect with the seller in Madison.”

What were the biggest challenges during the transition?

August Felker: “The biggest challenge was managing the transition of leadership and retaining the seller’s team. I learned the importance of trust, clear communication, and aligning incentives to ensure a smooth handover.”

August Felker Business Stats

August Felker’s journey from purchasing a small insurance brokerage to scaling it into a multi-million dollar business involved:

  • Founded in 2008
  • Revenue growth from $1M to $15M
  • Employee count expanded from 6 to 15
Year Revenue
2008 $1M
2019 $15M

August Felker’s Method

August Felker’s approach to building a successful insurance brokerage included:

  • Building trust through personalized client engagement
  • Transitioning leadership with a focus on retention and alignment
  • Emphasizing high-touch, exceptional customer service

Tools and Resources

August Felker utilized:

  • Insurance software: Travelers, Chubb for managing policies
  • Accounting tools: QuickBooks for financial management
  • CRM: Salesforce for client relationship management

Key Notes

Key insights from August Felker’s experience:

  • Trust and relationship-building are critical in insurance
  • Early-stage leadership requires authenticity and adaptability
  • Understanding the importance of retention in an elevator asset business

Get Started in Just 5 Steps

Steps to follow when considering purchasing an insurance brokerage:

  • Research the target market and industry trends
  • Network and seek introductions to potential sellers
  • Secure financing and understand the financial requirements
  • Develop a transition plan with the seller
  • Focus on building trust and exceptional customer service

Conclusion

August Felker’s journey highlights the importance of perseverance, strategic planning, and understanding the unique challenges of buying an insurance brokerage. His experience serves as a valuable case study for aspiring entrepreneurs and searchers.