How Greg Geronimous and Robert Graham Compared Self-Funded Search vs Traditional Search Fund Models

Introduction

In this revealing debate, Greg Geronimous and Robert Graham compare the self-funded search vs traditional search fund models for entrepreneurs through acquisition. This comprehensive discussion covers the key differences, economics, ownership structures, and considerations that every acquisition entrepreneur should understand before choosing their path.

Self-Funded Search vs Traditional Search Fund Debate QnA

What is a traditional search fund?

Greg Geronimous: Traditional search is a partnership between searchers and investors where searchers receive upfront money, also known as search capital, from which they draw a decent salary and cover operating expenses for two years while they search for a business to acquire. Then they raise another round of capital to fund the deal, most typically from that same group of investors. The key tenets and key advantages of traditional search are the support and credibility coming from that investor group to help you find and close typically a much larger deal than what you would find in self-funded search, and support from that investor group to help you be as successful as possible and de-risk the operating phase to help you grow the business as much as possible and realize the greatest gains for everybody involved.

What is a self-funded search model?

Robert Graham: Self-funded search is an entrepreneur who wants to go acquire a business and what they do is they make the decision early on to fund their own search. So they’re going to cover whatever due diligence and search costs that they’re going to incur during the search phase of finding a business and kind of really manage that process for the most part themselves. Once they find a business to acquire though, oftentimes they bring in outside investors. Self-funded searchers have maximum flexibility – they can buy really as large of a business as a traditional searcher. By not taking funds up front to pay for search costs and due diligence costs, searchers don’t have to agree to all the strings attached that comes with that funding. Many self-funded searchers end up with a vast portion of ownership and control in the company they acquire, which is quite different from the traditional search side.

How do the economics compare between traditional search funds and self-funded search?

Greg Geronimous: In traditional search, the searcher’s ownership is broken up into a third, a third, a third of the 25 percent. So the searcher will get eight and a third of the common equity at close for finding the deal, eight and a third investing over time typically four years for staying with the business, and then eight and a third subject to achieving certain performance hurdles in the exit or the ultimate realization of the business. Forty-six percent of traditional search deals are larger than 12 million dollars of enterprise value. If you look at the Stanford study, there are 133 data points collected: 29 of those have searchers making over 8 million dollars, 42 over 4 million dollars, and 69 over over 2 million dollars.

Robert Graham: SIG searchers on average are ending up with 73 percent common equity ownership in on average 2.6 million EBITDA businesses. Traditional searchers end up with 10 or less ownership at closing of a median of 1.8 million of EBITDA. So the whole idea that these are giant businesses or larger than self-funded search is just not the facts. With a self-funded search you can get much better economics if you get a good deal. With the traditional side, you are going to be getting 10 or less at closing no matter how good of a deal you close. Everyone loves to cite the Stanford studies’ 33 IRR, but keep in mind those are the returns to investors, not the searchers.

What are the ownership and control differences between the two models?

Greg Geronimous: I would encourage anybody to take a poll of traditional searchers and ask them if they felt like they were an owner, the key owner of the business. I think overwhelmingly they would say as I had in my experience and the vast majority of traditional searchers that I talk to have, they have a significant amount of entrepreneurial autonomy, control, and true sense of ownership. I think there’s this misconception that board involvement, governance, accountability is all bad. The most common conversation that we have as board members with the searchers that we work with is how can we help you more, how can we support you to grow this business even more.

Robert Graham: On the self-funded side, generally speaking, you cannot be fired. You’re going to have majority control of the board, you’re going to have a controlling share of the votes. You’re not forced to report out in a certain way. Traditional searchers sign employment agreements, they’re expected to perform their jobs within certain parameters in exchange for a salary, they can be terminated, their performance is evaluated by folks who are in control. By any definition – the Department of Labor, the IRS, academia and anyone else objectively reviewing the amount of control that the controlling shareholders have over the activities of the searcher – they would be defined as an employee.

Which model offers more flexibility and optionality?

Greg Geronimous: Flexibility and optionality are the best reasons to go self-funded if you can somehow afford to go self-funded. If you’re interested in ETA but you’re also contemplating maybe I’ll do a startup if I have a startup idea and you want that optionality or flexibility, then I do think that the self-funded model is right for you. The flexibility to go for a very small business where if you go for a very small business, having the ability to flex up on the economics can potentially make that work. Or if you have a very targeted geographic search, so if you wanted to buy something around Milwaukee for example, that’s probably not going to work in a traditional context but you can certainly do that self-funded.

Robert Graham: The ability to acquire a certain geography, you really can acquire in just about any industry. You can even acquire a minority ownership in a larger business – you really can’t do that with traditional search. You can acquire franchises that have restrictions on ownership, and you can use some alternative forms of debt and equity that can’t be used with the traditional side. It’s not being able to buy a small business, it’s what you can do in terms of your structure and the types of companies you can buy. It’s just a maximum amount of flexibility, which is a huge help considering that even in the Stanford study, one out of three searchers don’t find businesses to acquire.

What are the risk considerations for each model?

Greg Geronimous: About two-thirds of traditional searchers will close a deal. If a searcher comes up empty-handed, if you’re a traditional searcher you were funded for two years, you’re given a salary working closely with investors building a relationship with them, and many investors will go out of their way to help traditional searchers who came up empty-handed find really interesting career paths after. When you think about risk post-close, typically traditional deals are larger with more cash flow to reinvest to grow the business, to stabilize the business with bigger teams with more resources, human capital resources to grow and sustain the business, with more support from more formal engaged boards.

Robert Graham: If you think about risk relative to risk between the two models, let’s say you buy a company for four times and you use 90 leverage right, you’re going the SBA route, that’d be a typical self-funded deal. The median purchase multiple in the Stanford study is six times, and how much debt is an average traditional searcher putting on their company? Probably 50 to 60 percent. If you model that out, the debt service coverage of those two deals is the same. How often are personal guarantees actually exercised? Very, very rarely. It’s extremely easy to shelter your personal assets with basic estate planning. A lot of self-funded searchers don’t even take personal guarantees, so I don’t think that there’s a clear risk advantage actually for traditional search.

Which industries are best suited for each model?

Robert Graham: Self-funded search is completely industry agnostic. As a self-funded searcher you could go find a deal and then go to the traditional search investors and raise on those terms if you wanted to, or you could go to traditional LPs, you could go to high net worth individuals, you can use conventional debt, SBA debt, unitranche debt, you can do whatever you want. You can buy a company in any industry. The idea that all or a large portion of traditional searchers are buying these fast-growing software companies that make them multi-millionaires – well, only less than one out of five traditional searchers actually buys a software company.

Greg Geronimous: Traditional search is industry agnostic, looking for good businesses to buy. It does allow for growthier businesses, also for more boring, much less sexy businesses. If you look at aggregate returns, there are a couple deals that have skewed the overall return profile, but you can’t ignore the dozens and dozens of data points on equity earned by traditional searchers. This is actual money taken to the bank under this known model, proven quantity that has delivered a lot of success, and not just monetary success but also autonomy, professional development.

Who is each model not a good fit for?

Greg Geronimous: Traditional search is not a good fit for somebody who has a very, very narrow geographic focus. Somebody who’s not sold on doing entrepreneurship through acquisition might want to test the waters but may still be open to doing a startup, so they have the flexibility to pivot. Some people like the idea of starting really small, sort of their first acquisition pretty tiny to get that experience, get their feet wet – that’s probably more appropriate for self-funded search.

Robert Graham: The biggest group that self-funded search is not a good fit for is folks who don’t have a way to fund two years of searching. If you can put in the sacrifice of limiting your personal expenses for two years and getting ready to eat some broken due diligence costs, which if you do due diligence the right way can be a pretty small number if you’re wise about it, then self-funded search is going to be the way to go. If you don’t have that ability, you don’t have much of a choice unfortunately. What happens exceedingly rare is that a traditional funded searcher does a search, has a successful exit, and then does another traditional search. I have never seen that happen.

Business Model Comparison

When comparing self-funded search vs traditional search fund models, several key differences emerge that entrepreneurs should consider. The following table outlines the main distinctions between these two approaches to entrepreneurship through acquisition.

FactorTraditional Search FundSelf-Funded Search
Upfront CapitalProvided by investors ($300K-$400K)Funded by entrepreneur
Ownership PercentageUp to 25% (with performance hurdles)Typically 70-80%
Deal SizeMedian $1.8M EBITDAAverage $2.6M EBITDA
Geographic FlexibilityLimited (expected to relocate)Complete flexibility
Industry FocusIndustry agnosticIndustry agnostic
Exit ExpectationsInvestors expect exitNo exit timeline required

Key Considerations for Each Model

When deciding between self-funded search vs traditional search fund models, entrepreneurs should carefully evaluate these key factors that will significantly impact their acquisition journey and outcomes.

  • Economic Trade-offs: Traditional search offers smaller percentage of potentially larger businesses, while self-funded search offers larger percentage of typically smaller businesses
  • Control vs. Support: Traditional search provides investor support but less control, while self-funded search offers maximum control but less built-in support
  • Risk Profile: Traditional search spreads financial risk but has more strings attached, while self-funded search concentrates risk but offers more freedom
  • Success Rate: Traditional search has documented success rates with about two-thirds finding deals, while self-funded search lacks comprehensive data
  • Long-term Vision: Traditional search typically aims for exit within 5-7 years, while self-funded search allows for indefinite holding periods

Tools and Resources for Searchers

Both search models require specific tools and resources to effectively identify, evaluate, and acquire businesses. The following resources are commonly used by searchers regardless of their chosen model.

  • Deal Sourcing Platforms: Platforms like BizBuySell, Flippa, and MicroAcquire help searchers find potential acquisition targets
  • Financial Analysis Tools: Tools like LivePlan, Finagraph, and traditional Excel models for due diligence and valuation
  • Legal Resources: Law firms specializing in M&A such as Cooley, Wilson Sonsini, or specialized boutique firms for acquisition documentation
  • Financing Options: SBA loans for self-funded searchers, private equity and search fund investors for traditional search
  • Network Building: LinkedIn, industry associations, and alumni networks for connecting with brokers and potential deals

Key Notes

The debate between self-funded search vs traditional search fund models reveals important insights that every aspiring acquisition entrepreneur should consider before embarking on their search journey.

  • Traditional search funds provide upfront capital and investor support but come with significant equity dilution and less control
  • Self-funded search requires personal financial resources but offers greater ownership percentage and decision-making autonomy
  • The Stanford study frequently cited for traditional search shows 46% of deals exceed $12M in enterprise value
  • Self-funded searchers on average secure 73% ownership in businesses averaging $2.6M EBITDA
  • Both models can be successful, but the right choice depends on individual circumstances, risk tolerance, and long-term goals

Get Started in Just 5 Steps

Whether you choose self-funded search vs traditional search fund models, these five steps will help you begin your journey as an acquisition entrepreneur.

  • Assess Your Financial Situation: Determine if you have sufficient capital to self-fund your search or if you need to pursue traditional search funding
  • Define Your Search Criteria: Establish clear parameters for industry, geography, size, and type of business you want to acquire
  • Build Your Network: Connect with brokers, investors, and other searchers who can provide deal flow and advice
  • Prepare Your Toolkit: Develop financial models, due diligence checklists, and acquisition processes before beginning active search
  • Execute Your Search Strategy: Begin systematically sourcing, evaluating, and pursuing potential acquisition targets

Conclusion

The choice between self-funded search vs traditional search fund models represents one of the most important decisions an acquisition entrepreneur will make. Traditional search funds offer the advantage of upfront capital, investor support, and access to larger deals, but at the cost of significant equity dilution and less control. Self-funded search provides maximum ownership percentage and decision-making autonomy but requires personal financial resources and may limit access to certain opportunities. Ultimately, the right choice depends on individual circumstances, risk tolerance, and long-term goals. Both models have produced successful outcomes, and entrepreneurs should carefully evaluate their personal situation before choosing their path.