Introduction
Learn the private equity investment strategy that helped John Caple build Hidden Harbor Capital Partners into a $1.9 billion AUM firm. In this interview, Caple shares his journey from investment banking to founding a successful private equity firm, his approach to investing in founder-owned businesses, and valuable lessons from his 25+ years in the industry.
Founder Success Story QnA
Can you tell us about the early days and everything postgraduation?
Yeah, yeah, yeah so graduated from college I became an investment banker this was way back in the day so I graduated in 2 I think I’d read Barbarians at the gate and got all excited about it ended up working at a firm called Alex Brown and Sons which is which is no longer in existence it was bought by Banker trust and then credit s but did uh Investment Banking in San Francisco primarily actually biotech if you can believe that but really enjoyed it had kind of a two-year run there learned a ton I then went and was a CFO of a of a startup uh and this was sort of before people were doing startups it didn’t end up working very well or kind of going anywhere but got some good experience went back to business school went to Wharton so that was a an awesome thing and then after business school I sort of didn’t know what I wanted to do and so I got a job in consulting which I think is what people do when they don’t know what they want to do I worked at Banning company for six years spent a lot of time uh I had a bunch of corporate clients but a lot of time with private Equity firms and so everyone from folks like the carile group on down to to some lower Middle Market firms and really really really enjoyed working with private Equity very smart people this was back in the days where we were doing strategic due diligence for private equity and and Bane obviously kind of invented that product when I was at Bane we were really the only ones doing it we almost had no competition and so learned a ton got a job in private Equity so I I met the guys at Hig Capital down in Miami most folks don’t know this but the original hiig team is primarily from Banning company the consulting firm and I joined when it was Tiny we were I think a $300 million fund when I joined I tell people Sammy and Tony took me to uh to lunch my first day they’re now on the Forbes list of 500 richest people in the world so things have changed but uh learned a ton at hiig saw huge growth there and you know it had grown so much in the six years I was there that I was sort of buried a couple levels below got an opportunity to move up as a partner to a firm called comest Partners up in West Palm Beach was there for six years invested a very successful fund four there helped him raise fund five and then decided to strike out on my own so about eight years ago uh founded hidden Harbor with uh with two partners and another principal level guy who’s now my partner as well and you know originally our whole idea was I really had this view that if both hi and comest the way it worked was every partner sort of ran their own portfolio companies and they sort of did it their own way and that never made much sense to me it sort of struck me as hey shouldn’t we have a bunch of standard op like as an example management incentive plans why do we have 10 different ones why don’t we just figure out one that works and use it but that’s true across a whole bunch of things right and so the whole idea was shouldn’t we have a standard Playbook we’re using every time and and that was kind of the idea that founded hidden Harbor and we still have it it’s on our website you can read it we call it our value creation engine but it’s a set of standard things that we do every time in every portfolio company and it’s it’s really a powerful thing I think that helps us be much more successful so as I said we’re now eight years into hidden Harbor 45 employees 1.9 billion in assets under management it’s been a it’s been a great uh journey and a lot of fun
Little bit still about the early days of hidden Harbor uh first of all how did you meet the partners and how was the early days of you going from the idea to actually raising the first 260 million fund?
Oh awesome question so my uh my partner David is my best friend I met him 25 years ago the first day at Bane together he was the best man in my wedding he had his twin brother as his best man by the way so I’m still offended by that but we’ve gotten over it so he’s like my best buddy and he was at a Clear Lake Capital company he’s a he’s actually an operator not a private Equity guy um I was you know at comest we just started talking and we said we should just do this together we then called A guy by name Chris paldino uh David and I had worked with Chris at Hig so he’s someone we knew really really well super excited to have him and then our fourth partner to really start was a guy named Andrew Joy who had worked with me at comest and so it was all people that knew each other had worked together that wanted to be value investors too right like we’re a value shop we’re paying five to eight times EIT off for things and and that’s a strategy and a style of its own and you really need to be partnered with other value investors and so that’s how the the the kind of four of us got together and we just said hey let’s go raise this thing you know our first office was like one room and four of us kind of sat back to back I remember we had this massive whiteboard and we would write down we we had I’ll never forget we had a we had a set of things we needed to do it was high net worth fundraising finding a placement agent hiring a team getting deal flow going and building a back office so we literally had each of those five things up there and then what we were working on and that’s what we did we we probably started in March April really announced the firm in July and we were fundraising by September it took us as I said two years to raise that fund the funny thing is we raised $65 million in our first meeting so literally the first fundraising meeting I ever had was with this European group they had been kind of calling me saying we’re interested and I said hey we’re not ready yet we’re not ready yet finally they called and said hey we’re going to be in Miami in August would you meet with us I said yeah I would love to you know my partner David was on vacation but yeah we’ll drive down there by the way Chris and Andrew hadn’t even joined yet right so we sat down in this hotel in Miami with them it was the first time we’d ever given the hidden Harbor pitch so we we we walked them through what we were planning on doing and at the end of the meeting they literally looked at me and said John would you take 65 million I said well you know I don’t know that’s a big check I don’t sure we could do that they said we’ll close in 12 weeks I’m like wow okay yeah we probably have room for one investor that looks like that this is literally my first meeting ever and I’m like this is going to be easy man I’m the man right like 65 million in my first meeting we were only targeting 250 we’re you know a quarter away there I didn’t raise another institutional dollar for 12 months after that so that’s just the way fundraising goes and um you know it was great because we raised that money we raised some high net worth money that gave us the ability to go do our first two deals then we had you know some deals we can talk about and until you have deals that you’ve done it’s all talk talk right it’s two guys in a pitchbook once you have a deal or two well then all of a sudden you can talk about those deals and why you did them and why they’re good and what your due diligence look like all stuff that’s a huge step forward those two deals let us raise you know about another 50 75 million we then did two more deals that led us do a final close at 265 and and then off we went
I mentioned David being your best friend uh there’s a lot of people who who work with different people uh by the way are you as a personalities are you similar different same interest Hobbies like?
Yes and no so like as you can tell I’m pretty extroverted he’s almost totally introverted but we like doing a lot of the same things I think I think it’s that we share the same values is what really matters right so when we were starting hidden Harbor the first thing we did is we wrote down our values which I know sounds like a bizarre place to start like shouldn’t you start with what kind of deals we want to do how big the fund’s gonna be also no we start with our values and um and they’re still on our website today literally go look at them they haven’t changed and so it’s really that we share a very similar set of value vales and kind of how do we want to treat each other how we going to treat the outside world and and we also share a very similar view of kind of private equity and how to add value and all that stuff then just as friends you know look we both like to golf we both like to do a bunch of that stuff but I think I think it’s really those things that are the most important and and have stood Us in such in such good stead you know kind of during our our partnership
I’m asking because uh being best friends starting a business together there are people who would like to do that but for for some reason haven’t done it mostly probably because of the uh stories when things are not going well so how has it been for you when maybe deal is maybe performing as good as you expected or there are some so-called tough times because eight years is is a long time so how has it been?
I don’t understand how to describe it David’s like my brother right he’s literally like that and so David and I just have no there’s no me him there’s just kind of us and so so and that’s kind of the way we work as hidden Harbor in general right so when we do a deal we all do a deal at Hidden Harbor we all voted yes in the deal we all own the deal if the deal goes well everyone gets credit for it because we all voted yes if the deal goes poorly well we all get blame and we’re going to lick our wounds together and so now someone has to be the lead on a deal but that lead can actually change over time at Hidden Harbor and when a deal is not going well as opposed to taking pot shots about it it’s like hey anyone got any good ideas like I’m I’m open for ideas you know you want to come on the board I’d love to have you on the board and so it’s just we don’t play the game that way which is so different than every other private Equity Firm I’ve ever worked for like if you were in our monthly portfolio review what that usually word looks like in private Equity is like everyone takes pot shots at each other’s deal that’s just not the way we do it we’re like engaged and how do we get better and so you know it’s a kind of once again that goes to our values like one of our core values is one team and that’s just the way David and I interact right and so you know part of it is just kind of what are your values and how you going to work together and and and because of that you know we’ve had a deal that was a zero and and we have another deal that’s struggling so we’ve had one that’s zero and a bunch and another that’s struggling we also have a bunch of deals that are 51x too so like overall we’re doing great but there’s always going to be things that don’t work and you know the our approach is like that’s not that’s not someone’s fault it’s all of our fault so how do we fix it together as opposed to kind of pointing fingers
So let’s go and talk a little bit about the fundraising and uh could you share some of the War Stories over your career and uh maybe some uh uh extremely eye openening stories maybe?
Yeah you know um I’ve been doing it a lot for a lot of years now I think one of the things I tell everyone is like you never know who’s going to invest so our second largest investor in fund one I mean was a total throwaway meeting that our our placement agent just like we were literally happened to be in New York and they’re like well we should just go see these guys because we’re in New York they ended up investing $40 million in our fund so you know you never know and you never know and by the way I I’ll never forget I had I never forget a meeting I had an LA with a with an endowment and um I literally thought it was one of the worst meetings I ever had I’m like oh my God that guy hates me literally called back the next day hey we’d like to we’d like to do a follow-up meeting that was great so you just never know kind of who’s gonna actually end up kind of getting there I think that my advice for people that are fundraising I have two key pieces of advice one I think the more you can disclose the better like LPS are really looking for people who are very open and honest and so if you saw our fundraising deck we tell them everything here’s how we value everything here’s how we do everything it’s all just there and so there’s nothing you know literally they don’t call me for anything we just tell them everything two you have to have a really good articulation of your strategy and why it’s repeatable and why you’re going to make money and hey we’re a bunch of Smart Guys isn’t it so like what’s your strategy what’s your process why is that differentiated for the market and why are you going to make money consistently I was just at a an annual meeting of one of our investors and one of the things he said to me he like the thing I like so much about you guys is like what you do is so straightforward and you can describe it it like everyone understands what you do it’s really hard but it’s very straightforward and then when I look at your portfolio it’s it’s not like you say you do a but it’s really B it’s like you literally do exactly what you said you’re going to do and and I think that’s kind of a key to fundraising but look it’s a ton of fundraising environment out there right now
You’ve been in this for a long long time uh I’ve heard stories both from private Equity Venture Capital uh that there has been people who pretty much keeping eye on you for years and years and years maybe not investing on your first fund maybe even on not on your second but they see how how good you are again you’re building this relationship they they see you as a as a human as a business owner they see your values and then fun three comes and boom they’re they’re all in so what has been your experience with relationships building them maintaining them all that?
It’s exactly that so we just raised a new fund we probably brought 10 new investors in three of them I met with multiple times for fund one multiple times for fund two and by the way these are like big blue chip you know investors that everyone would know and so you it really is and you know what I told what I tell my I think a lot of private Equity guys tell their placement agent like hey you know I don’t want to meet with someone that isn’t going to invest I don’t want to waste my time blah blah blah I tell my placement agent I will meet with anyone even if there’s no chance they invest in this fund if there’s some chance that at some point in the future they would be a good LP I am happy to meet with them I will never you know sort of come down on you for a meeting where they don’t invest or they’re not really all that interested like that’s okay because it’s a long time by the way one of the investors that just came in was an investor of mine at comvest 15 years ago so these relationships do get built over a long period of time and and I think the question is do you do what you say you’re going to do and that’s the way you really build relationships with investors is telling them what you’re going to do and then doing it like we we talk a lot about how our strategy at Hidden Harbor has gotten more focused over time like we’ve really honed in on what the the best hidden Harbor deals are but every deal we do today like would have fit with what we put in our very first pitchbook and so that whole idea of doing what you say you’re going to do I think is is really critical and a big part of developing those long-term investor relationships
You’ve been in this game for a long long time uh how has the fundraising landscape evolved over the years?
It’s gotten a lot bigger so both private equity and the lp Universe have both gotten a lot bigger so a lot more money is getting raised there’s a lot more private Equity firms I think folks have gotten a lot more professionalized as well so I think you’re getting better and better questions from your LPS that really know what they’re looking for and I think that’s generally a good thing I think the the biggest change has been over the last two years so the fundraising environment over the last two years has gotten radically more difficult um because interest rates are up multiples are down people aren’t selling things that means LPS aren’t getting money back that means they struggle to invest more money in new funds so for the first time in the 25 years I’ve been in this business LPS are getting much more picky and selective they’re reuping less and there’s a lot less money for new relationships and so that’s meant that the fundraising environment is very very challenging I think what you’re seeing out there is is a very bifurcated fundraising Market the best managers are still raising money very quickly we raised money in four months and you know we had probably 2x you know kind of demand than than what than sort of the size of the fund that we wanted to cap it at on the other hand you’re you’re either in that scenario or you’re in the it’s taking two years to raise a fund it used to be that if you were a pretty good private Equity Firm you know you didn’t raise in 3 four months but you got it done in six to 12 and that was kind of typical now it’s sort of either four months or two years and so I do think it’s gotten much more difficult I do think for the first time in the history of private Equity you’re really starting to see a number of firms go away private Equity has been a business where we kept creating new firms but not a lot of old firms went away you’re really starting to see folks go away I think it’s a big change for our industry and probably a good thing
Now we talked about the fundraising let’s talk a little bit about evolution of private Equity itself and how has it changed uh over 20 25 years at least what you have seen?
Yeah it’s crazy right so if you think back 25 years ago I think there are two huge Evolutions in our industry every like most people used to be generalists back when I started right like people like at Hig we were like we we didn’t have industry specialization or anything we were generalists and almost everyone was and now like that doesn’t work anymore e even if you’re at a generalist shop they then you know segment things by industry and so they have a whole series of kind of industry experts like you just can’t be competitive anymore unless you’re really deeply knowledgeable about the industry you’re investing in and I think that you know that advice and by the way I think all these Evolutions apply to the search fund community and the hold cook community and all these kind of folks that are trying to do that right like look at how private Equity is involved and incorporate that in your and what you’re doing so I think that’s been a huge Evolution everyone now is an industry expert and really knows what they’re doing or not everyone but but I think all the successful people are doing that the second thing is really this focus on operations right so you know 25 years ago you bought a company sat on the board and that was sort of it right like there wasn’t this kind of deep operational engagement that we have today and and look various private Equity firms are in various stages of that right frankly a bunch are still in the buy a company sit on the board and that’s kind of it some folks have hired you know small operations teams that are maybe doing some stuff but if you go look at like what a Vista or a KKR doing or a Cerberus or one of these guys they have huge teams of operational experts that are really overhauling these businesses and that’s really what we’ve built at Hidden Harbor on a much smaller scale but we have 16 people in our operations group now and and that’s a huge Delta and what I’d tell you is the skill set it takes to acquire a business and the skill set it takes to run a business are actually very difficult or very different and very few people actually have both and and and right because there’s lots of great operators out there and you put just a great operator in charge of a private Equity Fund like the history of that’s really bad actually you have to know how to do deals knowing how to run companies is really different and so I think it’s something that’s really critical to think about it’s how are you going to do both really well in private Equity often times it’s building out some form of an operations group but but for the for the search fund guys and the hold code guys I think you know it’s it’s something you got to think about how do you do both well
So John tell me about operating and investing at the same time and how does operating at the same time help you to be a better investor and vice versa?
I mean it’s funny I think they’re kind of different skill skill sets actually so I I have we have six total Partners but one of our partners is is my partner David I’ve already talked about he is just our operator he doesn’t do deals at all all he does is Drive our portfolio companies and he’s 100% focused on that and on the other hand you know our you know we have five kind of deal guys that are driving deals and so I think they’re just really different skill sets actually is it helpful to have a bit of an operating background as you go to do deals sure there are lots of incredibly successful investors that don’t have much of an operating background at all I don’t know that you need to have an operating background to be a great investor our firm tends to have more operating backgrounds of our of our Partnership of the six of us five of us used to work in Consulting and only two used to work in that’s three used to work in investment banking so we have a number that did both but it’s a Consulting you know so we are actually operationally heavy kind of an backgrounds but um I don’t know that you need to have it you know I have we there are great investors that have almost no operating background and they learn it over time
Now three pillars of successful investing uh sourcing selecting and servicing uh what are you best at what are you worst that has you changed over time?
Okay so I think the so that’s an interesting question the better question is what can you be better at right like like if you think about private Equity where can the source of competitive Advantage come from so I would argue that there’s almost no competitive Advantage anymore in selecting it’s really hard right like if you’re doing particularly if you’re doing sort of you know widely banked deals which if you’re doing anything of any real size you’re probably doing you know they’re going to send out the book to 100 plus private Equity firms you’re going to compete against everyone else that went to HBS and Wharton and you know the odds that you’re going to sort of just be a better investor these days I think are low and and and oh by the way you know the the process we all use to essentially evaluate deals it’s the same like we all do deals the same way at the end of the day I think there’s firms that are better at focusing and I think the key is to focus and know what your deal is but even then it’s hard to have massive competitive Advantage there I think you can have competitive advantage in sourcing I didn’t used to think this I now do so I think you can probably be on margin better at sourcing I think if you’re buying bigger deals from the Middle Market Banks you can be ahead of deals you can know the industries better you can do all that kind of stuff and I think that can be very helpful I think you can Source deals from smaller investment Banks deal Brokers and all that stuff which is a pretty good Channel they don’t have a lot of big stuff but they have a lot of small stuff but I think the place where you can really Drive value is operating the businesses better being a better operator of businesses and that’s something that private Equity has not figured out everyone does it different um everyone has differ size operating groups with different things they do and if someone had figured it out we’d all do it the same way and so I do think that that’s where real competitive Advantage lies in private Equity
Now let’s talk a little bit the type of deals and investment preferences uh so what kind of deals do you typically look for at uh hidden Harbor?
Yeah so we do Industrials and business services um we’re targeting we’re a value shop we’re paying five to eight times four to eight times for deals so 48 times I so we are a true value shop um the thing is I don’t want to pay you know five times for a five times business I want to pay five times for a business that one day can trade for eight 10 12 times and you say well G John doesn’t everyone want to do that like that’s not exactly an Insight right so how the hell do you do that at any had of a repeatable basis and the answer is we’re buying founder and family-owned businesses and corporate car Vats only so we’re never buying from another private Equity Firm most of what we’re buying is5 to10 million in eah with rollup potential and then I’m buying businesses that have what I call fixable issues that will drive down valuation that is typically a Founder that wants to retire there’s no CFO there so there’s like some bookkeeper running the books it’s run on QuickBooks and the founder does what I call managing by walking around right which sounds awful but it works really well actually when you’re a Founder right you know every aspect of this business it’s great now at some point it becomes unscalable so we’re buying these businesses that just aren’t ready for private Equity prime time in all honesty and then what we’re going to do is we’re going to bring in our operations group our standard operating procedures we’re going to hire a team we’re going to put in new systems we’re going to put in a whole set of processes oftentimes we’re going to head on a rollup strategy and buy a bunch of things and grow you know that five to $10 million evah business to 20 to 30 and hopefully sell it to you know one of the Middle Market guys for a for a double digit multiple and that’s kind of what we do on a repeatable basis
Can you share uh an example of a company you helped to grow big time uh over over your experience uh how much you maybe paid for that how much you can share uh what did you do in a in a right away post acquisition over the next years and how it all ended once you once you sold?
Yeah so let’s talk about our our first our first business we bought which was a a business called Stella Environmental Services by the way there’s a you can go on our website and there’s a whole case study on it so um it’s kind of interesting but let’s talk about it so this was a business it’s in the um it’s in the it’s actually in the trash Logistics space so you take the trash to the end of your driveway you know a garbage truck comes to pick it up that garbage truck doesn’t actually go all the way to the landfill because landfills are too far outside of City centers at least in the US these days so it goes to what’s called a transfer station where it dumps out the trash and then that trash gets loaded into 18 wheel trucks and trucked out to the landfill so what Stella did is they actually ran those transfer stations that did the associated Trucking on behalf of the big Municipal Solid Waste uh companies so the city of Boko would Outsource trash to Republic Republic would Outsource uh sort of running the transfer station to Stella we bought the business this was uh this was owned by its banks actually it was part of a failed rollup they were selling it off we paid you know a mid single digits kind of right in the middle of our our range kind of multiple for the business it was doing you know seven of evah when we bought it over our ownership period we did six add-on Acquisitions paying on average less than five times we also grew the business organically pretty significantly by the time we went to sell it it was in the mid 20s sold it to a middle Market private Equity guy for double digit multiple hired a whole new team CEO CFO coo DT um this was a business that when we bought out was run on paper tickets so they literally would fill out a ticket at the landfill at the at the transfer station the trucker would take it to the landfill they’d put it in a pouch send it to Houston every morning and then they had like three people that would sit there and enter it into the computer was literally we put in a whole new electronic system so you can imagine how we just really transformed this business right like what we bought was a pretty good business actually but really only in one city no real management team run on paper tickets the only track record of growth they had had is they won three new stations in Omaha that were losing money what we sold was like a sweet private Equity growth engine right um a great team great systems a track record of organic and inorganic growth you two Middle Market private Equity guy can buy this add capital and grow it from mid 20s to 50 and that’s kind of what we do on a repeatable basis and I probably have you know a b i I could probably tell that same story just in other Industries in a bunch of our other deals occasionally we do do bigger deals and those tend to be the corporate car bats so we have a couple deals between fun two that are more corporate carbs
What about uh changing the team post acquisition what’s the statistically have been like uh changing the CFO changing the CF CEO how has it been based on your experience?
We’ve done 16 deals in our history we’ve changed we’ve put a new CEO in 13 times and a new CFO in 14 times but just to be clear we’re not firing people actually what we we’ve had to fire people unfortunately a couple occasions most of those aren’t firing people though most of those are the CEO you know is selling his business because he wants to retire and so they’re excited when we bring the new CEO in because they get to move to a more board rle and often times help us in Acquisitions and most of the times there is no CFO there and so we’re bringing in a new team really for the first time and and and we’re doing that almost every time
Now you mentioned uh in the beginning of the call that uh one or few deals have have not been going so well and one ended up in in zero uh can you maybe discuss uh what what went wrong and maybe you made a mistake or Market changed or what happened and what did you learn from this?
What happened was really Co I mean at the end of the day this is a business that uh managed multif family apartment buildings and as you remember in the middle of Co in the US we had this thing called the eviction moratorium right and so people stopped paying rent and that didn’t actually impact our business but when an owner all of a sudden you know you’re not sending them a check you’re calling them and saying hey if you want to meet the mortgage you got to send us a check you lose some customers and so it was a business that really struggled I think one of the things we did really well though is one the business at iida was down by about 50% and we we were in there we did did a detailed evaluation and we just said look we think this is going to be difficult to save we could have we could have put 10 million bucks in and saved it but we thought that would be good money after bad we just said look we’re going to we’re going to admit our mistake and uh and just move on it was also the smallest deal in our portfolio so it was a little bit easier to do that but we just did that I think the thing we did though was when we went in there it was easy just to say this is all Co and by the way it really was but what mistakes did we make can we really spent a bunch of time really engaging on what mistakes we had made and there were really three um the first is we had done a really bad job hiring our CEO CFO and coo here were all the wrong people and so it really caused us to look ourselves in the eye and say like what are our hiring processes they’re not working we totally overhauled our hiring processes we really embraced a process called top grading um now we’ve also we also brought in thirdparty evaluators on almost everything we do we now have just hired our first head of talent assessment who spends all of their time assessing people were hiring assessing current management teams so we’ve become really passionate about this by the way in fun two we’ve hired so much better teams it’s just been really really great second thing um this company uh had bad employ employee feedback from the start so we do quarterly employee surveys at every portfolio company and we have since the start of hidden Harbor and this company consistently had bad employee feedback and it wasn’t that we weren’t working on it because we kind of were but we didn’t make it nearly high enough a priority and shame on us right we had the data we knew this was a problem that we didn’t get it fixed we now have a a clear policy that if your employee net promoter scores below 20 fixing as one of your top three priorities and we’ve gotten really good at driving Employee Engagement and um and it’s a big win because engaged employees turn over less often they’re more productive and they’re better at performing you know either making products or performing services and so it’s actually a critical important thing by the way if you have good employee engagement you don’t have a hard time hiring people want to come work for you and so in an an environment where it’s hard to hire really good skilled blueco collar workers this is a strategic Advantage so that was the second thing we learned the third thing is when we got in there I talk to you a little bit our standard operating procedures and how we try to do things the same way every time this company said they’d implemented all our standard operating procedures but hadn’t really and so we then went out and spent the next year saying gosh darn it every portfolio company is going to implement at the time we had 24 of them and in the next year you know what we learned 24 is too many no they just they weren’t able to to digest that so we really simplified down what we call our value creation engine the 12 most important initiatives those are the 12 we do today and we’re much better today at really executing those every time so look we learned a lot from wayer um it was a really it was not a good outcome but I think one of the reasons our second fund is so successful is because we didn’t just blame it on the market we said what did we do wrong and how can we get better and I think frankly one of the reasons why we were so successful today is because we we we we learned our lessons and and that’s important
So a little bit about General insights uh as you’ve been successful uh just raised fund three people and investors have uh trust in you they they want to P you what do you think sets hidden Harbor apart from other private Equity firms?
I think we do a really good job communicating with our investors we’re extremely open we’re not afraid to admit our mistakes and we talked to them in a very open honest way about what we’re doing we we do what we say we’re going to do so you know we told them that we’re a lower Middle Market firm that does value investing in Industrials and business services and we’re going to have these standard operating procedures and all the stuff we’re going to do was in our first pitch book right not that we’re not getting smarter about how we do it but fundamentally like we’re doing what we always said we’re going to do I think we’re actually really good at kind of adding value and driving our portfolio companies I mean I I don’t know any other private Equity Firm that does quarterly employee surveys and is really good at driving Employee Engagement you know as I said you know outside of you know mo most private don’t even talk about that kind of stuff so I think we’re really good at driving those kind of things I think we have a really good you know we have a really good Bey team we have a seven person Bey team sourcing deals and we have a great um you know kind of investment team and so I think to really be successful you have to kind of do all of it really well and and that’s the that’s the that’s the key to really long-term success if you if you think your competitive differentiation is one thing that’s not sustainable usually it’s got to be five or six or eight things and so that’s what we try to do we try to do all of these things kind of a little bit better
Now little bit about you a personal question we are all different as as humans what routines and to follow to ensure you perform at the at the highest level levels are there any secrets because you’ve been in the industry for a long time you’re you’re doing very well so how do you recharge yourself after the long day after a tough week?
So let’s talk about the secrets because I think there’s one that’s like really critical so there’s a there’s a personality trait called persistence and people that are high on persistence um really are are really are very kind of structured right they want to do a and then B and then C and by the way if you if you change their priorities they get all flustered they don’t like that right they want to just execute ABC they want to know exactly what their their responsibilities are Etc people that are low on persistence love new things they love new ideas they’re always sort of looking they they almost sort of love the chaos right the new idea the thing they can go to okay to be in private Equity you have to be low on persistence because our world is chaotic and you get into the office on Monday morning and some portfolio calls you with something and the whole world blows up and like that’s just the way our our life works and that’s true of everyone that’s in entrepreneurship small business all this stuff right we’re all we all we all are low on persistence we like that chaos and that’s you know and when I interview people to like work for lower Middle Market companies like they’re all low on persistence because you you don’t get in this if you’re high on it you’re working at for or GM right where it’s very regular we’re all that way so so if you’re low that way you got to realize there’s pluses and minuses with that the plus is you love new ideas you’re able to handle the chaos etc etc the minus is you’re not very process oriented and things are going to fall through the cracks and so the most important thing I think in business is being process oriented create processes for yourself create processes for your business and your team so that you’re kind of consistently doing things the same way every time you know you have to have a weekly team meeting with your team you have to have you know weekly check-ins with your team you have to do quarterly check-ins you have to do reviews every year it’s all these kind of standard processes are actually really really critical and there are some like really small changes in your like personal process that can have a massive impact let me tell you a great I have a great example of this so when we had first raised our our our first fund um we did our first employee survey we said oh God you know because we didn’t do it during fundraising but we raised our first fund I think we only had 10 people we did an employee survey and and one of the things the employees told me was hey the communications here isn’t any good like we don’t know what’s going on I’m like what we have like 10 people here my my door’s always open you can just come in and ask me anything you want how can you tell me the communications aren’t good I’m like but just a second they’re telling me the communications aren’t very good so maybe I should fix this and what I did the only thing I did is we have a Monday morning meeting like every other private Equity Firm the first thing we start with now is announcements and I announce a couple things that’s going on and then I say does anyone else have any announcements and usually other people have announcements and our score on communication went from not very good to perfect like over overnight and all I did was one simple process change and so a lot of times these simple changes to like kind of your personal process can have massive impacts on business and business success and so I think we don’t talk nearly enough about them but and and because most people like us hate process right like I hate it I just need it and I know I need it and so I think that’s actually a really critical element of being kind of successful in business the long term
But can you maybe go more in depth on your personal level of what processes you have what do you follow and uh H how is it like what do you mean like I I I get up in the morning and I have a cup of coffee and um you know I’m not a morning person so I have 8 to 10 in my schedule blocked for me to like you know kind of just get ready to go to work right and and read the news and do all that kind of stuff um I tend to work a little later into the evening which is just kind of my personal process lift weights probably three times a week go walking another two um love to play golf as well love to fish a lot um I’m married I’ve been married for for over 20 years have two kids uh 17 and 14 I spent a lot of time you know with them going to to you know volleyball games and football games and all that kind of stuff which I love um my my my older is G be a senior in high school this year so I’m starting to face this idea that in like literally in four years my kids will be out of the house I no idea what the hell I’m gonna do with myself like what does that all look like it’s kind of very scary so that’s just a little bit about me and my kind of personal process and you know um I go to the office every day so worth three days a week in the office but I go there five days a week and actually you get a lot more done in the office so um it’s kind of how I approach things?
I I get up in the morning and I have a cup of coffee and um you know I’m not a morning person so I have 8 to 10 in my schedule blocked for me to like you know kind of just get ready to go to work right and and read the news and do all that kind of stuff um I tend to work a little later into the evening which is just kind of my personal process lift weights probably three times a week go walking another two um love to play golf as well love to fish a lot um I’m married I’ve been married for for over 20 years have two kids uh 17 and 14 I spent a lot of time you know with them going to to you know volleyball games and football games and all that kind of stuff which I love um my my my older is G be a senior in high school this year so I’m starting to face this idea that in like literally in four years my kids will be out of the house I no idea what the hell I’m gonna do with myself like what does that all look like it’s kind of very scary so that’s just a little bit about me and my kind of personal process and you know um I go to the office every day so worth three days a week in the office but I go there five days a week and actually you get a lot more done in the office so um it’s kind of how I approach things
Perfect that’s what I wanted to know and thanks for sharing uh little bit uh advice to Founders uh especially those for uh considering selling the business within the next year or two and maybe selling it to a private Equity Firm so what would you tell to them?
Okay got it I have three things that that I just think are critical number one if you sell your business to private Equity this will be likely for you the first time you’ve ever sold a business right I do this hundreds of times if you think that you can just that you’re just a smart guy and you’re not just going to get absolutely killed in that process you’re crazy right there’s a million little tricks I’ve learned over the years and and and and I’m not talking about me I’m talking about anyone that’s buying your business you’re going to get killed so you need good advice you need a really high quality attorney not your local local attorney who’s done your you know copy or lease and that stuff you need a real m&a attorney you need an accounting firm that can help you get your books records in the right place you probably need a deal broker an investment banker to help you navigate that process all of these people are really expensive offensively expensive but you need them when I go to sell a business I spend enormous amounts of money if I’m going to sell a business for 100 million bucks I’ll probably spend two to three million on professionals and I’m really good at this so you have to hire good people they’re going to be more expensive than you want and then you have to listen to them they know what they’re doing piece of advice number one piece of advice number two in a deal process the power always goes as the process elongates the power always shifts from the seller to the buyer because because um because uh you know in the beginning you have lots of buyers and by the end you’re going to only have maybe one party you’re working with and so over that process you’re going to see a big shift in power so how do you deal with that there’s two things you got to do one you got to be really prepared and prepared to move fast your business will not get better during a sale process so you want to make this process as quick as you can two you have to you want to tell the buyers everything upfront if I find out if you tell me about something upfront about your business you can position it in the right way I’m going to have to compete with a bunch of other buyers you know to to to to think of that fact in in a given way and um and and and your odds of me sort of accepting that are pretty good if I find it late in the process I’m going to assume all the worst about that and you have no power and that’s really hard for entrepreneurs right because we all started our business by like fake it to you make it right like that’s how that’s what you got to do when you start a business right you don’t call everyone and say well I really have nothing but please do business with me no you know and so it’s really really hard for entrepreneurs to do that and so this whole idea of really um disclosing everything up front and being ready to move move really quickly I think is is is really really critical for entrepreneurs and and they they don’t do it and they don’t want to do it or they don’t it’s like really against their kind of core core kind of how they are third thing um when you’re selling a business it’s critical to have a really crisp story of why someone should want to buy your business you’re going to hire an investment banker and they’re going to come up with a set of key selling points inevitably there will be 10 of them and you’ll sit down in this drafting session and anyone that has an idea will get written down as a key selling point and you’ll end up with this list of 10 things and when you have 10 key selling points you don’t have any because every single one you add subtracts from all the others because you know people only have so much um so much attention and so what I’d like you to do when you’re selling your business is come up with the three reasons why someone should want to buy your business and only three and the reason why you do three is actually people can keep three things in their mind at once but not four so it’s actually three is the right number and and maybe you could do four too but the whole point is like that forces you to say what really is it that is going to be the the thing that’s going to convince someone to buy my business and um and it’s a really and then and then during the sale process relentlessly go back to that stuff and um and I think it’s really critical to like tell a good story when you’re selling your business so those are the three things I sort of recommend uh to to people wanting to sell a business
Perfect I forgot to ask a question before I’ll do it now what is the most valuable creative skill in managing an acquired company is it the people management selling and marketing Factory and process Improvement add-on m&a?
I mean so we have a saying at Hidden Harbor uh people plus process equals performance and so it’s about hiring a great team and then putting in the right processes and so everyone talks about hiring a great team the question is like how do you really know you’re doing it are you really measuring it all those kinds of questions that gets back to this employee net promoter idea but then it’s it’s really all about processes and so the best run businesses have really good kind of consistent processes that they use and so I actually think that’s the most important thing you know there’s been a whole bunch of functional skills whether it’s selling or manufacturing or whatever um and every business is different and which of those matter is going to depend upon the business but the thing that always matters is the people in the process
Joh I’ve uh we’ve talked a little less than hour uh you’re very excited about the private Equity you you look very happy uh my question what do you truly enjoy the most of your chop?
It’s creating these kind of business success stories so that’s that’s what’s really fun when you buy a you know $7 million business run on paper tickets and you build it into this really cool kind of growth engine everyone at the business is pumped up to go to work because they know they’re winning in the marketplace like that’s fun and by the way it’s the same thing in building a private Equity Firm right like it’s fun to build hidden Harbor to recruit a great group of people that love coming to work every day and and you know that that gets me excited every day and and and and so that’s what I’m passionate about building great portfolio companies and building hidden Harbor and that’s what that’s what I get excited about every day
How has uh entrepreneurship and building the hidden Harbor Capital Partners changed your life and changed your family life?
I don’t I don’t know this changed my family life almost almost of all I mean so right I mean you know there were probably two years there where I was traveling so much that you know my my kids would have said you were kind of not around for two years um I still came to all their sporting events all that kind of stuff but that that was kind of tough um I think though you know the only way to be successful as an entrepreneurs you kind of got to burn the ships you know this is uh who was it one of the Spanish one of the Spanish conquistadors you know landed in the new world and burned the ships and like there’s no going back right and that’s a little bit of the way I think you have to think about building any business whether it’s a private Equity Firm or or any entrepreneur Venture um so I think that’s part of it um you know but I think in a lot of ways I haven’t really changed that much I still like to fish I still like to play golf I still like to hang out with my kids I’m still married to my wife who I love um you know none of that has has changed a bunch I’ll tell you I have a lot more fun at work now like I have fun every day that’s not true that’s actually not sure I don’t have fun every day there’s totally painful things about what we do at Hidden Harbor and running the business but it really is fun and I really do love it and um it’s fun to work at a place you really believe in and that’s that’s really been probably the biggest positive
Looking back on your life and your life today uh is it what you expected to be I mean there are I don’t know tens of thousands of young young professionals who would like to one uh they probably would like to do it now but especially in the future to run a fund which has like 1.9 million assets on the management so again is it what you expected to be everything what you do?
Um like in some ways yes in some ways this is sort of what I always really wanted but like how you get there is like who knows and there were so many kind of twists and turns in my career and successes and failures and um and I think that that um you know I think all success ful people had lots of failures in their life and understanding that I think is really really important you know and I I tell this to kids when they’re graduating college you know when you graduate college um you know you’ve probably never really failed before right you you’ve gotten good grades You Know da da and we live in a in a culture now where everyone gets a trophy right and you’re going to go out in the real world and you’re going to fail you’re not going to get that promotion you wanted you’re going to you know have a a deal that goes the wrong way you’re G to you’re going to fail and and the the people that are successful aren’t the people that don’t fail they’re the people that kind of pick themselves up and keep going and keep figuring it out and and you know as I as I look at all my my business school classmates a bunch of them are incredibly successful and very few of them had like straight up into the right careers they they they they had a success and a failure and they and they kept at it and eventually found found the right thing and so I think that’s that’s the biggest piece of advice I give people just keep at it keep plugging away and when you fail you’re not a failure you just had a you just had one that went the wrong way so go figure out one that’ll go the right way and keep at it
Let’s uh wrap up with a famous five how old are you?
I’m 54
Favorite book uh what kind uh in what genre could be both fiction business what’s what comes to your mind?
Probably Friday Night Lights
What car do it drive?
Oh I have a GMC Denali like I don’t care about my car it’s like I think you’re either a car guy or not and I am clearly in the not category I’m a boat guy so I have a I have a sweet boat that I really like and so I could care less about my car but I love my boat
What’s the best investment advice you’ve ever got?
I think I think at the end of the day the key to being a great investors is to not fall in love so I remember back in my days it Bane we were doing strategy due diligence for these private Equity firms and you would get in and deliver your final report and you could like see it in their face they were in love there was nothing you could tell them about their deal to make them fall out of love I mean you just see it and and um the one thing about hiig Capital the thing that they’re by far the best at they don’t fall in love they just don’t and it’s part of the culture if you go to IC and you’re kind of pounding the table on your deal there’s no way you’re getting it done you got to go to IC and be very balanced this is what’s good these are all the risks they are very real risks I hate the whole idea of risks and mitigant no no no there’s real risks let’s talk about it on what could go wrong here and there’s always things could go wrong um and so I think staying dispassionate not falling in love is the most important thing and it’s also true that everyone falls in love I fall in love we all fall in love it’s like impossible not to and so you got to know that and then do your best not to and um I think that’s the most important thing in in being an investor is not falling in love and not falling in love with your portfolio companies either because it’s just as easy to fall in love with how great they are and by the way when you write that book to sell your company you’re going to convince yourself how great it is and forget about all the stuff that’s not so good so just know that that and uh and try as best as you can not to fall in love know that you’re going to and just be aware of it
And last one where can people find you?
Oh I’m on Twitter so you can find me there uh I’m sure you’ll link to it in this in this uh in this I’m also on LinkedIn uh and so people can reach me in either place and uh yeah happy to happy to help folks uh happy to give advice all that kind of good stuff
John Caple Business Stats
John Caple has built an impressive private equity firm with significant assets under management and a strong team. Here are the key statistics about Hidden Harbor Capital Partners:
- $1.9 billion in assets under management across three funds
- 45 employees including investment professionals and operations specialists
- 16-person operations group dedicated to portfolio company value creation
- 7-person business development team focused on deal sourcing
- Invested in 40+ companies across Industrials and business services sectors
| Fund | Size (Millions) |
|---|---|
| Fund I | $265 |
| Fund II | $465 |
| Fund III | $800 |
John Caple Method
John Caple’s private equity investment strategy focuses on value investing with a systematic approach to creating value in portfolio companies:
- Target founder and family-owned businesses with $5-10 million EBITDA and rollup potential
- Pay 5-8 times EBITDA for businesses that can eventually trade for 10-12 times
- Implement the “Value Creation Engine” – 12 standard operating procedures across all portfolio companies
- Conduct quarterly employee surveys to measure and improve engagement
- Replace management teams in most acquisitions (13 of 16 CEOs and 14 of 16 CFOs replaced)
John Caple Tools
John Caple utilizes various tools and methodologies to implement his private equity investment strategy effectively:
- Top Grading – A comprehensive hiring methodology used to assess and select executive talent
- Quarterly Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS) surveys to measure employee engagement
- Standardized due diligence processes across all potential investments
- Systematic post-acquisition value creation playbook implemented in every portfolio company
- Third-party evaluators to assess management teams and key hires
Key Notes
John Caple’s journey offers several key insights for aspiring private equity professionals and entrepreneurs:
- Success in private equity requires both strong investment skills and operational capabilities
- Having a differentiated and repeatable investment strategy is critical for fundraising success
- Building long-term investor relationships requires transparency and doing what you say you’ll do
- Standard processes are essential for consistent results, even for entrepreneurs who naturally resist structure
- Learning from failures is as important as celebrating successes in building a sustainable firm
Get Started in Just 5 Steps
For those looking to follow a similar path to John Caple’s success in private equity, here are five key steps to consider:
- Build a strong foundation in investment banking, consulting, or operations to develop core skills
- Work at an established private equity firm to learn the industry and build your network
- Identify partners who share your values and complementary skills
- Develop a clear, differentiated investment strategy that you can articulate to investors
- Create a systematic approach to value creation that can be replicated across portfolio companies
Conclusion
John Caple’s journey from investment banker to founder of a $1.9 billion private equity firm demonstrates the power of developing a clear investment strategy, building strong partnerships, and implementing systematic processes. His focus on value investing in founder-owned businesses, combined with a rigorous approach to operational improvement, has enabled Hidden Harbor Capital Partners to achieve remarkable success. For aspiring investors and entrepreneurs, Caple’s story highlights the importance of learning from failures, maintaining transparency with stakeholders, and balancing deal-making skills with operational expertise.